All Segments
Why China's manufacturing economy is dominating — Arthur Kroeber
30 segments available
Arthur Kroeber is a leading researcher on Chinese tech and macro, a founding partner at Gavekal Dragonomics, and author of "China's Economy: What Everyone Needs to Know". It's the most useful, detailed resource I've found of how China actually works. On this episode, we discuss how China achieved high-tech manufacturing dominance, and where they'll go from here. By Arthur’s account, the Chinese government is like a giant VC fund: they decide on key priorities and then spend hundreds of billions of dollars subsidizing ruthless competition at the local level. They are willing to lose huge amounts of money for a few of their bets to pay off: at China’s scale, effectiveness matters more than efficiency. There's also a growing bipartisan consensus that we need to combat China's rise. This doesn’t make much sense to me. China is a big, powerful country at the frontier in many fields, and its economy is intricately tied in with our own. Being instinctively adversarial is both unsustainable and risky. Arthur and I discuss how we can create a productive, mutually beneficial version of this relationship. 𝐄𝐏𝐈𝐒𝐎𝐃𝐄 𝐋𝐈𝐍𝐊𝐒 * Transcript: https://www.dwarkesh.com/p/arthur-kroeber * Apple Podcasts: https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/dwarkesh-podcast/id1516093381?i=1000713627073 * Spotify: https://open.spotify.com/episode/2EXad7ZEt0oXezigqd7WLe?si=45d9402e6fce4095 * Get Arthur's book: https://www.amazon.com/Chinas-Economy-Everyone-Needs-Know%C2%AE/dp/0190239034 𝐒𝐏𝐎𝐍𝐒𝐎𝐑𝐒 * Scale is building the infrastructure for smarter, safer AI. In addition to their Data Foundry, they just released Scale Evaluation, a tool that diagnoses model limitations. Learn how Scale can help you push the frontier at https://scale.com/dwarkesh * WorkOS Radar ensures your product’s free trials go to actual users. Radar uses 80+ signals to distinguish malicious bots from real people, eliminating costly free-tier abuse. See why companies like Cursor, Perplexity, and OpenAI use Radar by visiting https://workos.com/radar * Lighthouse is THE fastest immigration solution for the technology industry. They help you understand your options and navigate applications for expert visas like the O-1A and EB-1A. Explore which visa is right for you at https://www.lighthousehq.com/ref/Dwarkesh. To sponsor a future episode, visit https://dwarkesh.com/advertise 𝐓𝐈𝐌𝐄𝐒𝐓𝐀𝐌𝐏𝐒 00:00:00 – We should reconcile with China 00:22:07 – BYD, Tesla, & Chinese EV industry 00:38:08 – Will China have a Japan-style financial crisis? 00:45:26 – Local debt situation is manageable 00:58:23 – If CCP is so competent, why isn’t China richer? 01:05:53 – How China keeps tech under control 01:34:32 – Does China win AI? 01:44:21 – Communication with China key for AI safety 02:10:55 – What foreigners get wrong about China 02:18:19 – China-US relationship future
Segments Timeline
The Dilemma of China's Wealth
Arthur Kroeber discusses the implications of China's potential wealth parity with the United States. He explores the criticisms surrounding China's manufacturing export model and the sustainability of its trade surplus. Kroeber emphasizes that the core issue isn't just about China's wealth but how it achieves that wealth, highlighting the political and economic differences between China and the US.
"Today I'm interviewing Arthur Kroeber, the founder of Gavekal Dragonomics, a research consultancy focused on China, and the author of China’s Economy. What Everyone Needs to Know. A friend recommended..."
Political Systems and Economic Models
Kroeber delves into the systemic political differences between the US and China, explaining how the US's identity as a leader of democracies complicates its relationship with China's authoritarian model. He argues that while China's economic organization benefits the global economy, it poses challenges for US domestic policy and social cohesion.
"In principle, from a welfare standpoint, I think it would be great if China became as rich as America. But that’s likely to have difficult and destabilizing political consequences, because the Chinese..."
Integrating China's Power into the Global Economy
In this segment, Kroeber addresses the need for a framework that allows China's growing economic power to coexist with the rest of the world. He discusses the importance of establishing agreed-upon rules for international interaction, emphasizing that the current lack of such agreements leads to tensions and misunderstandings.
"They won. The result was that you created a world where most major countries were democratic. They operated on market economic systems. We were heading towards a world of convergence of systems where ..."
The Nature of Great Power Competition
Kroeber challenges the notion that great power competition must end in the collapse of one side. He argues that China's political system, while different, is not inherently evil and that the US must find a way to coexist with it. He draws parallels with other nations and questions the adversarial stance taken by the US.
"A lot of what's going on right now is scapegoating of China as a way of diverting attention from decisions that need to be made domestically about income redistribution and macroeconomic policy and so..."
China's Economic Model: A Success Story
Kroeber asserts that China's economic model has been successful on its own terms and is deeply integrated into the global economy. He discusses the implications of this integration and the challenges it presents for the US, emphasizing that the relationship is beneficial for both sides.
"There's a few different questions in there, so let me break that down. The first thing that you alluded to there. Essentially, is a Cold War the right framing for whatever this conflict is with China?..."
The Future of Governance in China
In this segment, Kroeber speculates on the potential outcomes of a change in China's governance. He suggests that any new government would likely retain many characteristics of the current regime, emphasizing the historical and cultural roots of China's political approach.
"There’s another sense in which it's not going to go away. Let's say you could wave a magic wand and make the CCP disappear tomorrow and replace it with something else. What would that something else l..."
Negotiating a Grand Bargain with China
Kroeber discusses the potential for a grand bargain between the US and China, particularly in the realms of AI and manufacturing. He advocates for increased openness to Chinese investment in US manufacturing, arguing that collaboration could revitalize the US industrial base and benefit both economies.
"Let’s go back to this discussion about what should be the grand bargain between the rest of the world and China. I live in Silicon Valley and as you know, a big topic of conversation is AI. In particu..."
The Dual-Use Dilemma
Kroeber explains the complexities surrounding technology transfer and investment between the US and China, emphasizing the dual-use nature of modern technologies. He discusses the challenges of regulating investments due to concerns over data security and military applications.
"And if you did that, basically you would be saying that whatever we're in with China, it's not a cold war, because we are willing to have high levels of direct investment by both sides. You might want..."
China's Desire for Technological Sovereignty
Kroeber highlights China's ambition to avoid being pigeonholed in low-value manufacturing and its desire to compete in all technology sectors, including AI. He argues that expecting China to accept limits on its technological development is unrealistic and counterproductive.
"That is a legitimate concern. In my ideal world, you would have a lot more Chinese investment in the United States, but it would be very carefully regulated in the same way that China very carefully r..."
The Reverse of Technology Transfer
Kroeber reflects on the narrative that China has 'cheated' the US through technology transfer. He discusses the potential for the US to learn from China's experience, particularly in the automotive sector, and how this could inform future collaborations.
"It just doesn't work that way. It's funny because one of the main arguments that China hawks will make, or one of the big parts of the worldview, is that China really cheated us. Our companies would i..."
China's Automotive Strategy
Kroeber recounts China's historical approach to building its automotive industry through joint ventures with foreign companies. He explains how this strategy initially failed to produce competitive domestic manufacturers, leading to a shift in focus towards electric vehicles.
"could be done in reverse very well. If you go back to the early 1990s, China recognized that pretty much every other country that had gotten rich had done so in large part by building up an automotive..."
Leapfrogging to Electric Vehicles
Kroeber discusses China's pivot to electric vehicles as a strategic move to leapfrog traditional automotive development. He details the government's support for companies like BYD and the impact of foreign investment on enhancing domestic capabilities.
"All of the technological inputs continuously came from the foreign partners, all of the design ideas. The local partners were never able to succeed. In volume terms, you had a lot of smaller scale, lo..."
Tesla's Impact on Chinese EV Market
Kroeber analyzes the arrival of Tesla in China and its influence on the local electric vehicle market. He explains how Tesla's success prompted Chinese manufacturers to improve their design and consumer appeal, ultimately leading to increased competition.
"What they came up with in large measure was renewable energy and specifically electric vehicles. They started having a pretty comprehensive set of subsidies and other kinds of industrial support for c..."
The Role of Subsidies in EV Development
Kroeber evaluates the significant subsidies provided by the Chinese government to the electric vehicle sector. He discusses the long-term vision behind these investments and the challenges of measuring their effectiveness in fostering a competitive industry.
"So BYD and its competitors said, “Okay, this is the part we have to figure out. How do we achieve this?” Basically, they recognized that they had to up their design game. Among other things, they went..."
Central Planning vs. Market Forces
Kroeber reflects on the effectiveness of China's central planning in identifying key industries for development. He contrasts China's approach with historical failures of similar strategies in other countries, emphasizing the need for adaptability in industrial policy.
"Then the thing that finally flipped the switch was this catalytic foreign investment that showed the Chinese companies what they needed to do to actually compete in the consumer market. Then they got ..."
China as a Giant VC Fund
Kroeber likens China's government to a giant venture capital fund, willing to invest heavily in various sectors with the understanding that only a few bets will pay off. He discusses the implications of this approach for China's economic strategy and global competitiveness.
"China has a list of key industries. It's called the strategic emerging industries. They came up with it basically in 2010. It built on previous iterations of industrial policy. Most of it is not reall..."
Export-Driven Growth vs. Closed Economies
Kroeber elaborates on the significance of an export-driven economy in fostering technological advancement. He argues that unlike closed systems, which can become complacent, China's focus on global competition drives continuous improvement and innovation. This segment highlights the historical context of China's economic strategies compared to Japan and other nations, emphasizing the necessity of maintaining an outward-looking approach.
"I guess I'm still confused on why this works. Many other countries have tried similar things. MITI was a Japanese version of this, right? Yeah. Look at their economy now and their high tech sector. Th..."
The Role of Domestic Competition
This segment focuses on the competitive landscape within China, where domestic companies face pressure from both local and international players. Kroeber explains how this environment encourages innovation and validates successful government policies. He contrasts this with Japan's more insulated market, underscoring the importance of competition in driving technological progress in China.
"You can't compete just on price, you have to compete on raising your game. Japan did this successfully, Taiwan did this successfully, Korea did this successfully. China's done that successfully. So th..."
China's Long-Term Investment Strategy
Kroeber discusses China's long-term commitment to industries like solar energy, detailing how the government has strategically supported the entire supply chain. He contrasts this with the U.S. approach, which often reacts negatively to failures. This segment emphasizes the importance of a supportive ecosystem for industrial policy, showcasing how China's willingness to endure short-term losses can lead to significant long-term gains.
"That's really important. Then just the sheer scale at which they were able and willing to support what appeared to be losing bets for a long time does matter. You could contrast their view, for exampl..."
Lessons from Japan's Economic Stagnation
In this segment, Kroeber reflects on Japan's economic history, particularly the factors that led to its stagnation post-1980s. He draws parallels between Japan's financial practices and China's current economic strategies, highlighting the differences in how both countries manage their financial and corporate sectors. Kroeber emphasizes the lessons China has learned from Japan's mistakes, particularly regarding cross-shareholding and financial stability.
"manufacturing, high competition, and international participation across many, many sectors of the economy. They all converged to create success for themselves. I want to put some of these bureaucrats ..."
China's Unique Geopolitical Position
Kroeber discusses the geopolitical context of China's economic strategies, emphasizing its status as an independent actor in a dangerous neighborhood. He contrasts this with Japan's reliance on U.S. security, arguing that China's existential national security needs drive its economic dynamism. This segment highlights the implications of China's geopolitical situation on its economic policies and future growth.
"just interviewed Ken Rogoff, so Japan's top of mind for me. It's really interesting that even though Japan had this export discipline, maybe the reason that the growth didn't continue after the 80s is..."
Financial and Corporate Sector Dynamics
Kroeber explains the structural differences between China's and Japan's financial systems, particularly the lack of cross-shareholding. He argues that China's separation of financial and corporate sectors helps prevent the macroeconomic issues that plagued Japan. This segment provides insight into how China's financial policies contribute to its economic resilience and ability to manage debt.
"It's a good question. I would start by emphasizing the ways in which China is very, very different from Japan. The central thing that is really different and lies at the root of a lot of this, is that..."
Avoiding Japan's Debt Crisis
In this segment, Kroeber addresses the debt challenges facing China, particularly in the property sector. He contrasts these issues with Japan's historical debt crisis, explaining how China's financial structure allows for more manageable debt problems. Kroeber emphasizes that while China faces significant challenges, its approach to debt management is fundamentally different from Japan's, reducing the likelihood of a similar crisis.
"Japan had a system where banks owned equity in these giant industrial companies and trading companies, and vice versa. There were these cross shareholdings, which meant that essentially the entire eco..."
Local Government Financing and Infrastructure
Kroeber discusses the role of local government financing vehicles in China's infrastructure development. He explains how these loans are backed by anticipated land appreciation, drawing parallels to Japan's economic issues. This segment highlights the interconnectedness of local government debt and infrastructure investment, providing a nuanced view of China's economic landscape and its potential vulnerabilities.
"Everyone was holding shares of one another. So the banks’ capital got eroded because a lot of their capital was tied up in the land and in the stocks which were collateralized by land. So they were un..."
The Local Government Financing Model
In this segment, Kroeber reflects on the local government financing model in China, which initially capitalized on undervalued land assets to fund infrastructure development. He explains how this model was supported by the central government and the China Development Bank, and how it has evolved over time, especially post-2008 financial crisis.
"from the Japanese companies. Interesting. This is just stuff from your book that I'm citing back to you. You talk about these local government financing vehicles which are backed. The local government..."
The Evolution of Infrastructure Financing
Arthur Kroeber elaborates on how the infrastructure financing model in China became problematic after the 2008 financial crisis. He discusses the shift from controlled lending practices to a more reckless approach by commercial banks, leading to wasteful projects and a struggle to unwind the resulting debt.
"capitalize some of the future value of these things and use them to finance infrastructure development. This was not a rogue policy that local governments came up with on their own. It was actually sp..."
Understanding China's Debt Levels
Kroeber provides insights into the complexities of China's debt levels, discussing the challenges of double counting and the distinction between formal and contingent debt. He compares China's debt situation to that of the US and Japan, emphasizing the unique aspects of China's economic structure.
"What happened was that after the 2008 financial crisis, the government said, “Oh, we just have to spend a lot of money to gin-up growth because there's been this global economic catastrophe.” They did..."
The Macro Leverage Issue
In this segment, Kroeber addresses the macro leverage issue in China, noting that while the debt levels are high, they are manageable due to the local currency denomination. He discusses the implications of high debt on growth and the importance of understanding the structure of debt servicing.
"So I still think that that is fundamentally a local government fiscal problem, which ultimately is a central government fiscal problem. If you look at the consolidated balance sheet of the central and..."
Debt and Economic Growth Dynamics
Kroeber explores why middle-income countries like China struggle with high debt-to-GDP ratios despite potential for growth. He discusses the historical context of debt financing in China and the challenges of transitioning from low-productivity infrastructure investments to more productive economic strategies.
"It also matters what the debt goes to and who is actually formally responsible for paying it. Are there project flows or income flows that can be used to pay for it? The structure of the servicing of ..."
Revamping Economic Strategies for Growth
Arthur Kroeber concludes by advocating for a shift in China's economic strategy towards promoting domestic demand. He argues that enhancing domestic consumption and inflation could alleviate the debt burden and stimulate growth, drawing parallels to past strategies that successfully addressed similar issues.
"So if you look at China as a country that has average per capita income that's kind of like Brazil, China is way more leveraged than any other country of its level of income. That is potentially a pro..."