
16 segments available
Most people think revolutions are bottom up miracles. They are actually top down mechanical sequences. Kamil Galeev breaks down the engineering of regime change. We discuss why revolutions only happen in mono-centric states, why the French monarchy was actually a hostile takeover of the feudal order, and the crucial difference between the collapse of the Soviet Union and the rise of modern China. If these ideas interest you, we're building startup societies at Network School. You can apply online at https://ns.com. 2:22 People think revolution ends in freedom 4:50 Revolution as a hostile takeover 8:58 Beyond feudalism: medieval republics 16:21 The Sun King's parallel institutions 23:03 Complete breakdown leading to innovation 25:33 The art of not noticing things 30:07 Stalin was a citational priest 31:24 The surprising bureaucracy of Soviet terror 42:20 Russian crash vs Chinese reform in 1990s 49:35 Dragon's hoard mentality that ruined Russian privatization REFERENCES I. Books * Democracy in America: https://www.amazon.com/Democracy-America-Alexis-Tocqueville-ebook/dp/B008H4LC6W * Ancien Regime and the Revolution: https://www.amazon.com/Ancien-Regime-Revolution-Penguin-Classics-ebook/dp/B002RI9DUQ * The Foundations of Leninism: https://www.amazon.com/Foundations-Leninism-J-V-Stalin-ebook/dp/B0BF4NHM4N II. Studies and Articles * On the French Revolution by Kamil Kazani: https://kamilkazani.substack.com/p/on-the-french-revolution * On the art of not understanding things by Kamil Kazani: https://kamilkazani.substack.com/p/on-the-art-of-not-understanding-things * Russia's 1998 Financial Crisis in the Regions: A Case Study: https://worldview.stratfor.com/article/russias-1998-financial-crisis-regions-case-study * Yeltsin sends troops to oust armed forces from Parliament: https://www.nytimes.com/1993/10/04/world/showdown-moscow-overview-yeltsin-sends-troops-oust-armed-foes-parliament-fierce.html * How Putin Conquered Russia's Oligarchy: https://www.npr.org/sections/money/2022/03/29/1088886554/how-putin-conquered-russias-oligarchy SOCIALS https://x.com/ns https://x.com/kamilkazani https://ns.com/
Camil Kazani shares his background and insights on revolutions and transformative social change.
"Kaml, welcome to the state podcast. >> Thank you so much. Nice to see you. >> So, you've got a very interesting voice on X and a voice on Substack and um I think we're both sort of I don't know politi..."
This segment discusses the paradox of revolutions leading to increased regimentation and loss of freedom, illustrated by historical examples like the French and Russian Revolutions.
"know can can contrast that from the Russian nationalist perspective or the Estonian perspective and it's helpful because I think then you can sort of triangulate and and figure things out. And um ther..."
Exploring how French monarchy dismantled feudal structures to pave the way for revolution.
"did not have this pronounced capital in a sense that St. Petersburg. >> Well, it was preceded by the warlord era, right? So that almost was by definition like the Chinese civil war was preceded by the..."
This segment explores the complex interplay of power between local nobles and urban autonomy in medieval society.
"medieval order was indeed contradictory. M >> so first of all over most of country of course the ultimate power belongs to nobles so kind of noble land owners aristocrats of high pedigree who control ..."
This segment delves into the diverse systems of governance and law in medieval Europe, highlighting the legal intricacies and the significant role of local parliaments.
"one that's quote directly governed by the king is is in your view, the one that's not governed because the king doesn't have time to govern it. But the other ones governed by a count or a baron are ac..."
This segment discusses how Louis XIV of France managed power through creating a parallel government instead of abolishing traditional institutions.
"So from the perspective of French monarchy I would say these three with three primarily challenges to their power. So three primary internal security threats and uh starting from somewhere like 16th c..."
This segment explores the influence of governors in monarchy and the dynamics between local nobility and royal authority.
"Governor is always a great noble. He's some kind of duke or count or baron. He is he usually governed the same province where he grew up in where he hold his estates. He's connected by many familial u..."
This segment examines how periods of societal breakdown can lead to significant advancements and innovations in various aspects of civilization.
"and um and then in theory some other empire can be rebuilt again from this warlordism. Uh I think it is partially true because indeed probably experiences of most humans. They are worse at the times o..."
This segment explores how leaders manage perceptions of their authority and the strategic concealment of power in governance.
"more so than he was certainly in the first term, but even still, habits die hard. And I thought that was a very good insight, a very good way of phrasing it, that the ones in power basically are like,..."
This segment examines the Soviet regime's reliance on formalism and bureaucratic camouflage to maintain an appearance of legitimacy and governance, even amid brutal actions.
"wanted to give a decision, he wouldn't say, "Oh, it's my decision because I'm a boss. you. No, no, no, no. He would never do that. He would approach a bookshelf, take a volume of Lenin, find a quote a..."
This segment discusses the complex ethnic makeup of the Soviet Union and how internal nationalism contributed to its dissolution.
"not used any paper at all, just do it orally. And uh in Soviet Union, you would have protocol, you would have kind of decisions, you would have signatures, much more papers as a result, including when..."
This segment explores the chaotic transformation of Russia from communism to capitalism in the 1990s and its implications for democracy.
"[Music] kind of that they would have to um support it financially and another thing that was just afraid there will be too many centralations. Yes. And and the thing of it, you know, one thing that I ..."
This segment delves into Russia's tumultuous political landscape from Yeltsin's rule into Putin's ascent, highlighting the challenges faced in the 1990s and the implications for contemporary Russia.
"know, Yeltson was a drunk and um the there was like this whole thing with them shelling the White House and on and on and on. Basically, it really sucked to be Russian in the '90s. And then it was the..."
This segment discusses the struggles faced by workers during China's economic shift and compares them to challenges in the post-USSR environment.
"disillusionment disappointment a lot of um pain a lot of stateowned enterprises in China plenty of them they suffered or just were wiped out so generally speaking you have some of the processes you ar..."
This segment explores the critical impact of foreign investments and expertise on the success of transitions in economies like Russia and China.
"forth. A lot of that will have to be imported and it'll have to be gotten through and god knows what you know the customs are going to charge and so and so it's all kinds of uncertain costs which are ..."
A discussion on defensive thinking and awareness in modern society, highlighting societal parallels with past regimes.
"I'll not allow like any filthy hobbits to take a bit of it. So it was much more of defensive thinking. It's not that we will create something new and interesting as it was in China as that we will not..."