Selling to AI Agents: The Future of Commerce | Jun Kwak

0:00

Our service customers have 3x bigger sales pipeline generated through us than brands that are trying to use our software and run it themselves.

0:07

>> That's what intrigued me and led us to be one of your first investors.

0:11

>> Overjoy, we delivering sales and revenue teams to consumer brands.

0:13

We are able to offer services close to a software company margin right now.

0:19

>> Are you at all worried about the Frontier Labs cloning what you're doing and offering it as a skill?

0:23

We're a lot more excited and bullish than just more afraid about what the next launches are from DCIPS.

0:29

It's the reason why I think that all B2B SAS companies will have to become a service business.

0:33

I think you either become a service business or you just become a tool that models call eventually even that gets replaced. Well, hello everyone.

0:43

It's Jim Oanosi with yet another infinite loops.

0:46

Today I have June Quac, the co-founder of Overjoy.

0:52

One of the first portfolio companies that Oshanoscy Ventures, as opposed to our earlier investments, this one was one of the first that Oshana Ventures as an entity made. Jube, welcome.

1:08

>> Hey, thank you for having me.

1:10

So I thought that what might really be helpful for us and for our listeners and viewers today is for you to give kind of an account of the journey. Right.

1:21

I think a lot of people and thinking about founding a company especially young uh might have a lot of questions and I think that having seen how you guys have progressed over the last several years you've got a lot of answers but first off tell us a bit about the company and why you decided you know what I think rather than trying to get a job at McKenzie or whatever I think I'd rather start my own company.

1:51

So yeah, happy to share a bit about Overjoy first and how we um decided to start Overjoy instead of getting a job elsewhere.

2:00

Um Overjoy we um are basically delivering um sales and revenue teams to consumer brands.

2:06

So uh we actually started as a you know software startup building software stack for small msiz brands to scale wholesale channel.

2:16

uh when he first interviewed a bunch of brand founders uh even though they started their business uh as a direct to consumer model which is imagine you shoot like meta ads, Instagram ads and they direct them to their own website.

2:29

Um a lot more of these uh brands were trying to sell to other businesses like say local boutique shops so or other local stores and uh that's a pretty expensive channel because you need to invest in a full sales team and you need a dedicated software stack to run that.

2:44

So that's how we start building tools to help brands scale that channel.

2:48

And that went pretty well.

2:51

Uh we scaled uh and we were able to uh get to a decent revenue milestone, but we still felt like it would we weren't really solving the the biggest pain point for these brands, which was they still needed someone to run the the software stack.

3:03

So that's when we started um talking to more folks in the space and um we even saw some of our um like users taking our software and they were turning that into a consulting business and selling it at a 20x 40x price.

3:19

So that kind of helped us land to more about where we are today but happy to share more about that uh in detail. >> Yeah.

3:29

So tell me a little bit about the process in determining what made you target this particular market.

3:39

>> Um was it a big search across all of the available opportunities?

3:44

Was there just a a glaring uh empty space there?

3:47

What was it that made you do this as opposed to any number of other >> Yeah.

3:57

So I feel like I think that from very early on um like I had a so I I can I guess I can start from like my like like journey from like as a you know 13 14year-old >> please.

4:09

>> Um so I grew up in Korea.

4:09

Um and uh at that time I was like kind of like somehow I got into this like debate for the first time in English class and that was like fascinating because if you're like in Korea like you get like even though it's a peninsula it's basically an island with North Korea.

4:25

So basically um only way to learn about how the world works is through you know news and uh debate felt like you can actually talk about those topics with logic.

4:33

So I was fascinated by that.

4:36

Um and I started going to like debate tournaments.

4:38

Uh and I ended up winning three um like national championships in Korea at at age 15.

4:45

Um and then after that I kind of came to realization that you get to talk about all these topics but nothing gets like solved.

4:53

Um so that's when uh I like um like I was like one of my friends were into like game development.

5:02

So I was thought it was cool to build stuff on your computer.

5:06

So uh kind of started like myself teaching um my myself how to code um and started like built my first game, built my first app and that was like kind of like my like the second half of my high school.

5:17

Um I actually quit debate all you know public speaking uh mock trial everything and actually like uh went on learning how to code.

5:23

Um and um felt like if I get good at this I can actually go build things to like solve problems uh in the world.

5:32

Um and yeah, ended up kind of going to Yale.

5:36

I got um like a well I was one of the first 10 um like pres presidential scholars from Korea.

5:43

So that helped me kind of uh move here to the states and start my journey here and I was first felt like I should be a good engineer.

5:54

So uh that was all I was focused on throughout Yale.

5:56

Um I I ended up working at Google AI, um Snapchat, Robin.

5:59

Um and I think that's when I started feeling the itch of like, huh, I feel like I can now build something that people actually use.

6:09

What if I actually go try um build my own startup?

6:12

I think like um that so I had a stronger itch to build my own startup, but then I did not have like a clear picture of like what that space would be.

6:22

Um and I think in that sense really kind of going in through like a new gradator program um helped a lot.

6:27

Uh so I ended up going to um like SFB area we had a two big hacker houses and that's how I actually met my co-founder Alex.

6:38

We went from like you know so many different spaces from like know embarrassing to talk right now because like it's like you know so many bad ideas that we explored u but even in terms of like different areas we went from like fashion design tools to like you know crypto tools to um um like whole all all these different sorts of um spaces.

6:59

Um but then I came to realize that you should really like the people that you build for.

7:03

Um, and after going through different um, uh, domains, um, when I was talking to these, uh, brand founders, they're all super passionate about what they build, uh, what they what what they make.

7:14

Uh, and they're just like really cool people to, you know, hang out with.

7:18

And, uh, so even though we had like a very vague or key idea of like what problem we want to solve, it was pretty clear that we want to build like for the brand founders.

7:28

Um, so one of our first uh I remember uh talking to um one of our uh first uh customers um his name is Tyler.

7:36

He uh he uh found a brand called Cinnamon.

7:40

Um they want to be the Hershey's for Cinnamon um and her products.

7:44

And um I still text him um and like he's still very passionate about his his brands.

7:53

And I think like that uh from very early on even though we had very little idea about the space it was very clear that this is this uh space that we do want to be in and um uh people that we want to be around.

8:07

So um quite the underachiever by the way.

8:12

Uh what what did your debate experience teach you that you brought over to uh becoming a founder?

8:19

Because I I found one of the rarest things that I look for in founders are are people who don't want to just yap about things, right?

8:32

They because debate I love debate.

8:35

I think it's it's great and I think you can learn a lot of really good skills in it.

8:39

It but you've got to want to actually do something about it.

8:45

But what did your all of your debate experience teach you and what did you bring and and sharpened you as a founder?

8:56

>> That's a great question.

8:56

I think uh I just thought um I just thought of two things.

9:01

Uh one is um since I'm like you know CTO company, I lead a product engineering team.

9:06

um there's a lot of overlap between um like computer science and um and debate because like it's the code is essentially logic.

9:16

Um so I think that um when I was making that transition it actually felt like I actually never thought that I would be in like you know STEM like uh like field uh as a as a kid.

9:29

Uh I really didn't like math.

9:33

Uh but actually uh like coding, computer science uh it felt a lot more overlap with debate in that like you need to be logical, you need to uh understand um how machines work.

9:43

Um so that helped me like through that transition.

9:46

Um another thing is more about like how I work my co-founder Alex.

9:51

Um so fun fact he's also a debater too.

9:53

He he did debate as uh um as a high schooler and um one like superpower that we have as a team I think is we are not that like like emotionally attached to our arguments that we like um that we have um and like this is almost different from ego.

10:15

It's more like can how can you handle uh disagreements?

10:19

How can you handle these like attacks on on things that you strongly believe in?

10:24

And because we both come from debate background, I think it's easy for us to detach ourselves from what we are saying.

10:30

Uh and also for the attacks that the other person is like um throwing at me.

10:34

So that often times helps argument tremendously a lot because basically um we would go on for uh we'll talk about like what to build or how to build a specific like search feature.

10:47

um we both feel fine flipping our stance hour later because just logically the other side uh makes a lot more sense.

10:56

So I think it helps a a lot on for us to kind of uncover the truth behind what to build, how to build, how to sell, all these problems that you kind of face as a founder.

11:05

Yeah, I think the ability to pivot, the ability to have an open mind to a variety of paths forward, uh it it increases your cognitive space enormously.

11:18

And if you have like we're going to build X, right, and then X becomes the only thing >> and nope, that doesn't serve X.

11:28

Nope, that you can miss a tremendous amount.

11:34

And you actually experienced this, right?

11:36

Because you started realizing there was a whole different segment that you probably should be servicing.

11:43

Talk a little bit about that about the the services part of the business. >> Yeah.

11:50

Um so basically we um are more and more calling us and branding us as a service company because um what we realizing is small midsize brands um like lack of resources to spin up a full sales team.

12:10

Um and even though you give them the best tools, um it's hard for uh brands to use those tools uh or even orchestrate the agents to get to the most um like say AI pled or agentpilled uh sales team.

12:24

Um, so this was like a pilot uh experiment that we actually started running earlier earlier this year where uh so we've been the whole time we've been giving them um search tools, email campaign tools um and CRM to like create a full sales pipeline and turn them into opening orders.

12:43

What if we just deliver the outcome?

12:45

Uh was the thought that we had.

12:48

thought that we had. Um so we had a first set of brands where basically they still had access to software but then they they there's no need to do that just talk to our our team and we will run just give us tell us what you want like what outreach targets you want uh

13:03

what your messaging uh you want us to um like benchmark and that's and we just with that plan uh that we agreed with the brand we just went on and uh launched the entire outreach u campaign um and outreach sales process and brands were actually turn out uh it turns out that brands were happier that way. Um

13:22

Um brands got more visibility into like what things were how things were going.

13:30

Um and it was also not that far from how brands were working with um say in-house like hires or other agencies.

13:38

Uh but we were able to deliver that in a uh you know way more efficient way but also with better outcomes because we own the software stack, we own the agent stack.

13:50

Um so yeah now we have um three main services.

13:54

We have our service that basically we deliver interested buyers to these brands.

14:00

Uh we have conversion service where we own um say 100 200 active deals in their pipeline and we run all the manual works of email follow-ups sending them sample products uh uh figuring out the pricing and discounts for these wholesale buyers.

14:18

And also last one is reorder and expansion where what's interesting for these physical products unlike say software sales or insurance is that they're not on subscription.

14:26

you need to constantly go through the sales process for even your existing customers.

14:30

Um so every time there's a new product launch, you need to let them know you need to like get pre-orders and upsell u your existing customers for these new products.

14:41

Um so we have um the third service that's responsible for that.

14:44

And with that we are seeing um you know two person brands that had never had a sales hire be able to expand their existing accounts through uh through our services.

14:56

Um so I want to come back to that because I think I'm very intrigued by that part of your buildout.

15:03

But let's do a case study.

15:08

Um >> somebody is a small brand.

15:10

Let's say they're they've got a little shop and they want uh they don't they don't know about you guys yet, >> but then they meet you and they hire you, >> what do they look like when they discover you?

15:24

What kind of operation are they running?

15:27

What are the kind of sales numbers, etc.

15:31

>> And then what do they look like after they you've been fully uh uh embedded into their company? >> Yeah.

15:40

So um the truth is like we work with uh small brands that are less than 1 million GMV to like one to 50 and then 50 plus and then needs for these are all slightly different.

15:54

Um say like it's a very small brand say one or two uh founders just run the brands often times they don't have like a working wholesale engine.

16:04

So they come to us and they want us to like build out the entire uh wholesale.

16:08

>> And let me stop you for a second.

16:08

Can you give us an example of what are they selling? >> Oh yeah.

16:12

So, uh, one of our brands, uh, they sell, uh, leather goods.

16:15

Um, say like all the like leather coasters.

16:18

Um, and, uh, they are twoerson brand, uh, based in Minnesota, and they want to, um, uh, uh, basically they have an existing channel, but they oftentimes because they don't have a sales team, they just have their, uh, products on online wholesale marketplaces.

16:38

uh the market leader there is fair u and uh because of how markets are structured, they tend to pay very high commission for the sales that they get um through those marketplaces and they there's very less uh control on how you can increase your sales through those marketplaces because you don't have an in-house sales person.

16:59

Um so when they came to us they basically had um 10,000 customers uh that they like have they they only had opening orders and they never got reorders from those accounts.

17:14

>> Um and imagine like you try to do this like as a founder you would probably dig through all your um sales history.

17:19

The biggest problem actually is there's it's really hard to combine um your email data and your order data in one place.

17:30

Um you might think that oh we can use agents to do that but then that at scale to run that on like 10,000 accounts from five different sources becomes like a actual data problem.

17:41

Um, so oftentimes it's really hard to build that source of truth for someone to go in and talk and figure out a very simple question of which of my accounts should I go out and tell them about our new product launches.

17:55

So uh when they actually came to us um we uh took over that like on customer management side um and every day we have um 50 to 100 customer react win back campaigns where uh we know exactly what they purchased before and what is the best product that we can um recommend for them to like purchase next.

18:17

And that alone um they were able to go from zero to 15 like uh $15,000 in like overdraw attributed um revenue um in the past 30 days.

18:30

And that number is actually like keep going up because uh we kind of building up the the account management motion u for the wholesale channel.

18:38

and and give me uh an example of what does the workflow look like >> that determines Okay, so they bought this letter leather coaster or whatever.

18:55

How many different products are you researching that are available for this company to offer a returning customer?

19:04

And then what is the algorithm or the agent that determines no it's going to be this is the one we pitch them >> and why? >> Yeah.

19:12

Um so basically when brands on board to our um like service even though like they think that they are only getting like the sales service for us to uh power that we do onboard them to our entire software platform.

19:27

So uh when they come in we sync uh with their Shopify fair, QuickBooks um and um all their email uh communication channels as well and we have uh we build out their system of record where they can um see all their list of accounts um and what with that what we are able to do is we can start grouping them um and basically building out their uh you know customer profiles for their wholesale channel.

19:56

So, as we group them, we can now then see what are the top selling products um for each of these groups.

20:01

So, say um I'm a brand uh selling protein uh shakes.

20:04

Um I can group um these my customers based on like fitness gyms, um yoga studios, and grocery stores.

20:13

And then rank which of my products are the bestselling per category.

20:19

And then on a per account basis um these agents can go and look up all the products that this each account bought and has not bought and recommend the best sellers. >> Okay.

20:31

So uh you do kind of a you you look at what they bought from your client then you look at what they bought elsewhere >> and then you find the most adjacent thing that your client is offering to offer to them.

20:47

What is the what is the funnel look like in terms of you you you are now part of this smaller brand thing.

20:58

How do you how do you do AB like take me through is there AB testing or is it just yeah no they're buying a ton of this and this we offer.

21:09

Do you have to have a price advantage?

21:12

Do you have to have a quality advantage? Is there a secret sauce? >> Yeah.

21:17

So for any um like sales outreach um there's like target, there's message and there's a lot of um um like taxes on what the call to action should be.

21:27

So those are the three things that we do experiments for on behalf of these brands.

21:33

So I would say that the experiments actually happen more for c like new account um campaigns than their customer campaigns.

21:41

customer campaigns. Um but what that looks like is when the so same protein shake um brand will come in and we'll actually um launch three different camp like campaigns for different ICPS um and um because is what's actually interesting is even though a lot of brand founders think that they would

22:01

land better in certain accounts because that's what they saw in the retail uh channel in wholesale channel oftent times depending on how they bundle their products how they price it um what lands for uh wholesale is like completely different uh from their like the direct to consumer channel. Um so we do

22:17

Um so we do >> let me stop you there.

22:20

So and my guess is they're not aware of that. >> Yeah, exactly.

22:26

So um >> which is actually a hard thing for us to you know kind of like uh convince them and and that's why we do run experiments.

22:33

Um so when they first on board they uh fill out this um outreach form uh or like a it's basically like a that's our seed for their brand uh brain or we internal internally we call it brand wiki um and they uh so each brand founder would come in and they will identify oh I want to reach out to uh crossfit gyms and I want to reach out to um like grocery stores um and I might want to try yoga studio but I'm not sure how it will end.

23:04

Um then with that uh we have our um local business database um that maps all the local businesses across US and Canada and we are able to find the most similar retailers to the ones that they've identified.

23:18

Um and with that then we start um having um two or three different campaigns with slightly different email copies.

23:26

Um and the um it we change the brand voice.

23:28

We change uh what the offerings are because sometimes they want to just go send like sample products.

23:37

Sometimes they want to send give them more of a um catalog and let them know more about the brands.

23:41

Um so we will run these experiments and be able to um return it back to the brands and double down on the ones that work better.

23:53

>> So it's an iterative process.

23:53

And do you often find that your client, do they just go along or do they fight with you or what's the normal experience like? >> Yeah.

24:06

So, I think this is like actually the uh the the beauty of like how we've kind of transitioned from like a more of a software and subscriptionbased business into services >> because um if you go like two years back uh and look at our pricing page, a lot of our we we do the very standard SAS seedbased pricing.

24:23

um brands come in um they pay for say two seats, five seats and they pay for um credits which is essentially how many um new leads uh new you know potential email contacts that I can go and run outreach to.

24:39

Uh now fast forward uh to where things are now.

24:42

Um it's more of a outcome based pricing.

24:45

Um brands pay for 20 like 40 interested buyers.

24:52

uh and we there we actually abstract out the the parts of of identifying the targets creating like brand it doesn't matter if you do three campaigns or five campaigns or and run it on 500 buyers or you know 3,000 buyers uh essentially we deliver the outcome as if this is how you would um work with um um say like an STR um like or like a sales agency um and it's kind of like um it's more of a sales process runs on autopilot.

25:27

>> Who are your competitors?

25:30

>> Um so right now um there are uh more of a newer um like players.

25:35

Um but I think that um on the sales side uh we like haven't lost the deals to uh in our space.

25:47

our space. I think what we are more uh excited about is I think there are a lot of adjacent problems that these brands um yeah in terms of competitors um right now on the pure sales space uh we don't see any you know dominant players um

26:03

that like are competing with us uh we there are one or two newer players that we are still like um taking a look but we haven't lost any deals for um our current service offering of our outreach side and conversion retention side of our services. Um what I do believe is a

26:21

Um what I do believe is a lot of the um SAS companies in CPG will also move towards a service motion.

26:33

>> Um and even for us our customers are asking us to expand our offering to you know uh inventory management and accounting and other back office uh problems that they internally face.

26:43

So I think it'll be pretty exciting in the next six 12 months on how uh this pans out.

26:50

Um and I think there are players that are um on used to build accounting software or um other like um type of software stack that brands use that are also trying to expand their service uh to more broader offering.

27:06

So, let's take a moment and uh envision the person out there who is watching or listening to us >> and they're contemplating >> uh founding their own company. >> Yeah.

27:21

>> Take me through like the six things that happened that were completely not on your radar >> and how you dealt with them. >> Great question.

27:33

Um I don't have a six in my mind first, but I'll I'll start with things that just popped in my mind. >> Sure.

27:40

>> Uh I do remember when um SVB went up down and uh basically all our funding was locked up in this account.

27:50

Uh and I actually remember calling you Jim.

27:53

We're like we don't have any cash flow. This is this is it.

28:00

Um and um that like was actually right after we close our seed round.

28:07

We were like, you know, okay, like finally we can relax.

28:08

We can now know not worry about money for a bit and like go um build cool stuff. And yep, that happened.

28:19

Um and I remember uh calling you and we were able to I mean fortunately over the weekend everything uh was sorted out.

28:26

Um but um yeah, I remember um like assuring us that you actually went through multiple bank runs and how this will be handled.

28:35

Um and that was uh a big relief uh because as a first- time founder, I did not expect something like that could even happen.

28:45

Um other things um there there's a time where um like because we build a software stack we um have a lot of integration partners um and um there was a case that I would not like the exact name of the company but um one of the

29:02

integration partners um the the account uh was just um you have a one shared uh developer account where all the engineers share for lockins and no one really checks it in blocks Um and they were sending us all their updates and how we need to make sure we are

29:19

compliant with the the integration partners um app settings and uh it no one was checking it and one day uh all of our customers get an email it's very scary email that like oh like overdraw app will be removed from this uh from this after and we had to figure out how

29:37

um that we had to reassure our customers that that will not affect um the process and we were able to sort it out but That was also like one of those moments where it would be like did not expect that things like that could happen. Um so

29:48

things like that could happen. Um so yeah a lot of these like firefighting I think um I would say one more story there would be I do remember very early on um our search um I think this is also like when the all these um language

30:06

model providers um open AAI anthropic they do require you go through like a a moderation endpoint where you don't like accidentally try to look up um harmful content um but um what happened was uh one day we got um like a warning and then like we actually they actually like stopped our API access. This is very

30:27

This is very early on when it was just me uh and Alex and we had our founding engineer at the time.

30:34

But they basically cut our access to OpenAI and we were like digging through the data.

30:38

it turned out are um local business search products.

30:41

Um there were some people that were looking up adult stores and there's no filtering on whether that hits open end point or not.

30:53

So uh we had to make sure that gets uh that restriction was lifted which we did um through our um you know that people we have in our network.

31:01

Uh but yeah, all these things were definitely things that we did not expect uh and did not sign up for but it's just part of being a founder I guess >> and and I think also the way like for example the Silicon Valley bank um having been through a lot of that um that would freak any new founder out I think.

31:25

Um, and what about your clients though?

31:29

Did they get wind of all of that?

31:33

And what was their reaction like?

31:35

Because I also want to hear a bit about like are are your clients all of a certain type of personality?

31:44

Obviously, they're not technical would be my guess.

31:50

>> Correct me if I'm wrong.

31:50

Um, but is there kind of a translation tax that you have to pay to get them to understand? No, no, no, wait.

31:58

You can do this so much better. >> Yeah.

32:04

Um, I have like literally three different like thoughts that just popped in my head at the same time.

32:09

Um so there are definitely like um I think these like macro uh changes also do affect our customers too.

32:21

Um it could range from I I do remember like when there were all the change in like tariffs um and all these small businessiz brands are affected by that and they have all these questions they have.

32:31

It's very unpredictable what their next like six months of inventory would look like.

32:36

Um and we actually thought like those things do affect more emotionally even though like logically you should keep your outbound engine you should keep running yourselves process but then most brands gets like especially as like you know two person brand they get scared of all these the macro trends and they would actually pause or or change their like strategy of how they approach wholesale.

32:59

Um those are more like a like macro like economic trends.

33:03

uh even even for technical side um a lot of brands struggle like when there's a new launch like like Grockbot comes out um like claws new update comes out and they want to use these um agents they want to use these like frontier models in their workflows but they do struggle a lot in how to incorporate that into their products.

33:21

We even faced that too uh when we were rolling out um our sales agents uh products earlier this year and uh this was before we had the service motion.

33:32

Um so we do all these tutorials.

33:35

We try to um uh teach how of these brands can adopt use these agents to run order processing uh run um outreach and run customer management.

33:45

And it was actually um pretty difficult to explain the best practices when the best practice is changing real time.

33:53

Uh what we recommended a month ago is no longer the best practice because with uh new models um it's we actually do make changes on how things work.

34:03

changes on how things work. Um so um that's actually one of those uh things that contributed uh that that helped us made that decision to beam a lot more service forward because especially in when things are changing so quickly u um on on agents and and AI I think it's a lot easier for us to deliver the outcome with the best orchestration of software automation and agents for these brands

34:32

then for these brand brand founders to understand what's the you know cost difference between you know opus and fable and like show how how should I what is MCP how do I connect them um to my workflow so that's actually um our

34:47

was our conclusion and that seemed to kind of land better to our um customers lately >> and I are are they of a type of personality where they just are very eager to outsource And I mean your services is growing wildly. >> How do you scale that though? How how is

35:07

>> How do you scale that though?

35:07

How how is that going to scale?

35:09

Let's say you continue with the kind of demand you've been seeing recently. >> Yeah. >> Scale it for me. >> Yeah.

35:17

Um so whatever new services that the full sales service that that we have um in the past four weeks we actually had four like we 4x our effic operational efficiency.

35:29

Um now how we do that is um couple things.

35:32

I used to only um lead the product and engineering team but four weeks ago um Alice and I made the decision that I should also be leading the account management team because internal operations is basically product uh when we are a service for company.

35:49

Um so now uh I'm going to talk about like what this unlocks but then also all the like new problems I had to face with the unlocks actually is that now it gives immense clarity to a product person in any like uh companies like us because now you can you know what the service you're trying to like sell and what the price point is at first before you go and build all those um software and product that leads up to it.

36:16

In a sense, it removes all the guesswork on product development cycle because most of of like text startup 101, how do you build a product is you talk to users, you under you have these hypothesis on what those problems are and basically if you build X, it will solve Y.

36:35

And then you then you take it to the design and development phase where you try to figure out the best mockup, best prototype to solve that problem.

36:44

you implement it, you run QA and then you bring it back and see if that actually uh yielded results for your customers.

36:54

Now in the service world, you can actually go straight to what these brands want with um an actual sales expert delivering that service inhouse.

37:04

you keep labeling what are the things that are making this person inefficient, what are things that we can actually automate um with our software automations and what are things that we can actually improve with um agents.

37:13

Um so that's basically like our it flips how we build products.

37:19

You could go from out outcome first even in the internal product building side and you actually go backwards and um keep improving the efficiency of how you deliver the service.

37:30

So um that's what it unlocks um for us because before Alice and I would have all these debates on what what will happen if you launch this new ordering product.

37:40

We don't know we don't know how it will land.

37:42

We don't know how people use it but we'll just need to test it out and you spend all this time on trying to build that out and then it may or may not work.

37:50

It basically removes the guesswork and go and adds a lot of clarity on like what you're trying to optimize for.

37:56

Now internal operations wide it just means that I have a whole new set of problems I need to deal with internally.

38:04

Um and what we came to realize is um our account managers are essentially they're the experts.

38:09

essentially they're the experts. The reason why services um works is because um what we believe is uh for all of these services whether it's outreach or um like sales uh management is you have like say five to 10% where it requires human judgment um whether it's like does

38:29

this fit to what this brand wants to represent um does it fit with their like like strategy for this year all these like human like that these strategy that requires human judgment and review and the rest tends to be more of amplifying that and actually executing that plan. So that's essentially how we're trying

38:46

So that's essentially how we're trying to design our services and how we deliver that where each account manager owns that strategic part of all these um sales process and then the actual work that is involved there of making sure all the leads that we do market research on is qualified uh based on the criteria this brand sets.

39:06

uh making sure all the samples that get sent out matches the the budget that we actually set.

39:11

Um all those actual work that needs to be done on our platform becomes more and more automated with agents um and our software stack.

39:20

Um so basically what we essentially did is we built a a product a service loop where we match um each account manager with an engineer in our team and every day we review all the inefficiencies all the time um time sucks of our internal operations and that feeds into how we improve the agent quality and building like adding more things to our product road map to improve the workflow.

39:47

So um that actually led us to um getting the 4x efficiency improvements on our um full sales service um offering um and right now I can't show the exact margins but basically we are able to offer um services at close to a software um like software company margin right now. Hm.

40:09

Um, and as I was listening to you, are are there any universals because you're obviously dealing with very disperate brands, right?

40:17

Like leather goods and protein powders you wouldn't think share much in common, >> but is there a universal is there an pattern, if you will, that underlies marketing anything?

40:34

>> That is a great question.

40:34

>> That is a great question. Um and we'll uh right now what we've done uh is we have these loops like even among these agents because essentially we have the full data of what have all these brands tried and what works best and of course there are

40:54

differences based on their category or or their size >> but you get to then see all the trends like there are things that we used to recommend like anecdotally like say if you like if you attach a large like uh file or image on on your cold outreach email, it's not going to land on the inbox. But then we never knew that for

41:13

But then we never knew that for sure.

41:16

Whereas like once we hit like a critical mass of um outbound emails and we actually ran um analytics on what's the best like patterns that we recommend.

41:28

Um that actually turned out to be true.

41:30

Uh but then there are also some like counterintuitive things like actually turns out emojis on subject lines actually help but emojis on body is bad.

41:40

Um so we actually like learn from all these um like what people tried and all the actual outcomes and we can constantly improve what these agents can do on the outreach side.

41:49

Um and we've uh done these in a pretty still like semi-automated no like somewhat manual way.

41:59

way. But then soon what we are headed towards even in within our how we use and and improve our agents is uh for all the agents that run on these brands they're going to be able to do um basically I think the space is now calling self-improving agents u but now

42:17

they can actually see the patterns of these agents runs across these brands identify the patterns that actually yielded better outcomes um and constantly improve it and I think that's why whenever we launch new agents or service. Um we never try to launch like

42:29

Um we never try to launch like a standalone one that doesn't integrate with our stack because we want to make sure that data flows in.

42:36

We can actually see the full um outcome uh and whether that was you know know very good, good or bad.

42:42

Um and that flows in and can improve our software agents continuously.

42:48

Um so that's how we like determine like which space which new service we're going to launch.

42:54

it does it um can we actually have compounded data effect of um improving our um agent agent quality with those um added data sources to our platform?

43:06

>> And do do the brands that are your clients do they do they grock all this?

43:12

Do they do they really understand what's going on or are they just like yeah no you do it.

43:17

We love the fact that our sales are going way up but uh or or or do they really understand the process?

43:25

>> Uh so um I would say yes and no.

43:28

Um we do expose an entire software staff to our brands.

43:33

Um so this is actually like the reason why brands prefer to work with us than like some um third party agencies because they tend to be pretty secretive about like who they contact.

43:45

um and they have like their own like wall garden of like contacts or buyers that they work with.

43:51

Uh for us, uh we you know it's all about transparency.

43:54

We we we market ourselves as we're basically like a embedded sales department for your brand.

44:00

So you should have control on all the data and all the um software staff that we're building it for you and offer type surprised by looking at the CRM that is wellmaintained three months later because they only thought that they were getting like inbound leads.

44:13

Um so uh yeah um we probably not real time but then we um we don't hide anything.

44:22

We try to like kind of give them um the full exposure to um the underlying things that we use to run it because essentially uh we're constantly using our software and agents to to run this.

44:33

But then um you did point uh that does relate to like an interesting new problem that we're facing which is how we interface with brands is changing as we are evolving from a software company to a service company.

44:44

Uh because what we are realizing is a good chunk of um our customers are now just talking to us on email.

44:54

Um they just tell us what they want and things gets done.

44:56

Um and so uh right now our product manager Emil and I we're thinking a lot about okay what is the new interface uh that we need to build for our brands um because um it is different from like op like the assumptions is different.

45:12

We're not having those uh customers as a software user.

45:17

they're more like u a client for the service and what we need to report back or summarize or or explain what things are happening is changing um through this uh because of this transition.

45:32

>> Has a client ever come to you with a really good idea that you guys thought wow why didn't we think of that and then you actually incorporated it in your stack.

45:42

M so actually um having the main uh sales email um end with like would you like samples?

45:54

Can I send this send this to this address is now like a pattern that we like have a lot of our brands uh use.

46:01

But that was actually from like the few um you know people who were really like had this like um idea that even the uh the brands that sell products um that are really hard to send samples to they need to um create like a smallest the cheapest product and send physical samples um for them to uh for for the buyers to engage and understand the brands.

46:26

Um so that was actually from looking at uh and working with um uh you know brands sales managers in these brands that had those hacks and we were able to kind of um you know have more brands uh benefit from um those like uh sales hacks >> um and go through your customer acquisition uh funnel.

46:47

How how are you attracting customers?

46:50

Is it word of mouth from your existing client base?

46:56

What other ways are you getting new clients? >> Yeah.

47:00

Um I'd say right now uh still we are primarily um like outbound, but then we're increasingly having more inbound as uh now we have thousand customers um working with us um and I think now there's more word of mouth and um referrals coming in.

47:16

Um but for a long time uh our primary uh um sales engine was through our uh outbound engine.

47:24

And so basically what we give to our customers is essentially the same as like what we use in house to reach to other brands.

47:31

Um and I think that what I often tell tell to our customers is um like cold outreach and email is all about qual qualification.

47:45

If you reach out to um a store that is a good compatible buyer um store to your brands, then it's a business opportunity.

47:55

If it's not, it becomes a spam email.

47:57

So, it's all comes down to can you qualify and do a very deep market research to find the best retailers that matches your brand.

48:05

So that's what we've really tried to crack the code on in the last um couple years uh for our our outreach engine but also for our brands u outreach and um Alex went through four big iterations of kind of u making sure we can um do that.

48:23

Um there are a lot of like technical innovations that allow us to do things like this.

48:29

um like because models got cheaper and faster now um we able to u use like products like like clay to like score all these um uh businesses at scale but then there was even one more unlock uh this year with Jeff uh which is um system one model uh where it's uh because it's uh built to score things not write things uh it's way faster and cheaper four um qualifications of business opportunities.

49:02

So with that um we actually completely rebuilt um how we score um these brands on their intent on whether they want they are engaging with their wholesale channel.

49:15

Um and um this week we're actually building um bringing that to our customers starting with their service customers um because this actually increases um the quality of leads that they can reach out to um to for that outbound sales function.

49:31

>> And what what is the size of your total addressable market here?

49:36

>> Um so right now um there are uh uh 3 million um e-commerce shop by businesses um that that sell like physical goods um and uh only 700,000 of them are engaging in wholesale channel.

49:53

Um and that essentially is because wholesale is a pretty expensive um channel to run.

49:58

Um so um our first goal is to be able to um democratize that sales process and deliver this agent build sales department for these brands.

50:10

But I think uh this will be a second Shopify effect where essentially if you think about how brands were selling pre-shopify era um like you would still have to figure out how to put your products online.

50:24

You'd have to have developers and designers to set up your own website and then try to figure out how to get them pay.

50:32

uh all that um remove the need of having your internal tech departments um to and just go start selling as a one person founder.

50:43

Um there's still a big uh entry to be barrier uh for uh there there's still a big uh um barrier entry um for uh wholesale channel and what we're essentially doing is we are allowing even these smallest players to be able to um grow their B2B um wholesale channel. >> Okay.

51:02

So, let's say I've got again a little shop uh with my wife uh and we sell um snow globes.

51:15

Um and you're going to pitch me and what what does that pitch look like?

51:24

How do you get them excited about like wholesale?

51:26

That seems like a lot of a big headache to me, etc.

51:31

Wh how how how do you get them to become a customer? >> Yeah.

51:36

Uh right now um I mean our our sales team probably have a 10x better fish than than I do.

51:42

But um what yes I should tell them is um give us a shot and in 30 days we will bring you um 20 interested buyers um that matches your brand that that wants to stock your products on their on their shelves.

51:58

Um, and it's not just a one-time thing.

52:03

We'll build out an engine where we can constantly get that um predictable predictable sales opportunities every month.

52:10

And you only pay when we hit those targets.

52:14

>> Um, and now once you do that, uh, you will start having a sales pipeline of 50, 100, and 200 opportunities and someone will need to manage all the communications with those opportunities.

52:28

Now you can decide to hire someone to run that in-house or you can try to work with like a external agency or let us run that sales pipeline and we will handle everywhere from email replies, giving them quotes, um sending sample products, giving them um marketing materials to push them down the sales pipeline.

52:47

And essentially this this turns a very tedious um wholesale process into almost like a direct to consumer-l like simplicity where you you basically just focus on the orders coming in and the uh the opportunities coming in.

53:02

>> So June, are you at all worried about the Frontier Labs just essentially cloning what you're doing and offering it as a skill?

53:10

So I think that it's the reason why I think that all uh B2B SAS companies will have to become a service business is because I think that's there either uh there's only two paths.

53:22

I think you either become a service business and try to automate not just the software stack but also how you use that uh and build your proprietary data >> or you just become a tool that models call and eventually even that gets replaced.

53:40

replaced. Um so um I think that there there were a couple of reasons why uh Alice and I even earlier on like this year I think everyone was pretty shocked about like the newer cloud models um and how that impact each vertical um what when we saw our market uh it be the more

54:01

um data sources that you need to deal with essentially like a it's a data structure and data complexity problem where if your data is flat say it's a single spreadsheet and it it explains everything then it becomes very easy for one agents to just take over and abstract away the software stack. >> Sure. >> Sure.

54:17

>> But then now once you need to have you have two three four with all these relationships in between because for us we have list of businesses and then contacts and then their orders and then each of these sorts have locations and each of these products have inventory data and this comes from five different data sources.

54:35

this becomes hard for um someone to build or for agents to build and that makes it harder for um Frontier Labs to just like I've unless they're actually going into that very specific wholesale market.

54:50

Uh I think that's where it becomes harder for uh mall improvements to accidentally kill a space.

54:58

But then not just that I think with the service side what we are most bullish on is the amount of data that we are getting um just for our space um that also is tied to an actual like outcome um quality data um and we are able to constantly improve our service with that data and improve our agents with that data.

55:20

So uh this is how we can keep building um like our data modes um through services and this is why uh we're a lot more uh you know more excited and bullish and just more afraid about like how uh than the what the next launches are from DCI labs.

55:37

Um, and I I I don't know the answer to this, but um I would assume that that data set in and of itself is very valuable.

55:53

>> Uh, have you agreed with your clients that that doesn't get resold?

55:58

Um, so then it simply becomes an advantage for you uh and your company as opposed to others joining the field.

56:05

Um, how much time and you've been in the business for several years now.

56:17

>> When does that data compound to a point where it's going to be really hard for a new entrant to reach your level of understanding because you have all of this data verse them starting a new enterprise today? >> Mhm. Yeah.

56:34

>> Mhm. Yeah. Um I think for some of the more mature services like our cold outreach lead generation side of our offering I think we've already reach reached that point where um we have the best data um that fuels that engine but also the outcomes keep improving that where it becomes

56:58

really hard like Alice and I talked about how let's say we have to re like start everything from scratch you'll have to go through the exact same path to build out this product and then build out this current distribution and then get to a point where it constantly improves the model. We reach that point

57:11

We reach that point for our lead generation site um and our um service uh our full full sales service side.

57:20

Um I think we'll reach that point um in the next um two months uh because we've passed that pilot phase.

57:28

We have we're trying to build um data on these brands that are running the full sales process with us.

57:32

Um and we're now going through the um first set of loops to improve those agents with that data.

57:38

Um and so yeah, I think what in the next two months we'll reach the point where we will have uh that for our entire sales process that we offer for our brands.

57:49

>> And let's talk results.

57:49

uh what uh what kind of numbers are you seeing improvement for your clients uh from prior to when they hired you obviously but then with the with the new service model as well what what what kind of lift are you offering? >> Yeah.

58:08

Um so we ran um some data data analysis um and our service customers have 3x uh bigger sales pipeline um generated uh through us um than um brands that are trying to use uh use our software and run it themselves.

58:26

>> That that's just like extraordinary >> and yeah that and so it's it happened when it first launched uh for the first month and now six month in that still holds true.

58:35

So we were able to scale that level of like per like you know overall sales efficiency boost um as we scaled our entire sales um program.

58:42

So, but what what does that what does that curve look like, right?

58:47

Does like your 3x, which is astounding.

58:53

>> Does that then just flatten out?

58:53

Does it continue to improve?

58:56

What does that look like?

59:00

>> Um, so I think that's uh hard to say like what what's the what would the next like low hanging fruit would be or uh how we will get there.

59:08

Uh right now we're focused more on how can he um like optimize for um uh yeah so I think the um right now actually with a 3x boost and if you're we were able to deliver that for six months.

59:23

So actually we're trying to copy and paste that performance boost not on a lead generation side but on the full sales process side.

59:32

So that means can we 3x their conversion rate um but bring more of those opportunities to um close deals um and for those customers can we have a boost on the reorder rates.

59:44

So that's basically since we proved out that boost on the lead generation side we're trying to um bring that to the rest of the um their sales funnel and other uh and down the stack um to their conversion and retention problems.

59:58

And how sensitive are you to macroeconomic trends and like what happens during the next recession?

1:00:11

>> Um so I think for us the biggest thing is like can we be the the most affordable and also the most performing a best performing uh way to run your sales departments.

1:00:26

Um, so I actually think that we still have some brands where uh, oh, because they've worked with a sales agency for a while, I want to keep them for a bit even though they are offering at a way higher price um, at and actually performing way u, you know, less efficient than than us.

1:00:44

less efficient than than us. So I would actually think that say if there's more ex external pressure on these brands to run it in a lot more lean way I think we would be the best in the market because we are able to offer the same service or or better service um at like fraction of their price >> and and that's what intrigued me and led

1:01:05

us to be one of your first investors right like the the disintermediation >> my thesis has always been I call it the great reshuffle right and that all of the old playbooks are collapsing and uh there there's so much uh fat, if you will, >> uh from what what the old players were charging, the results that they were delivering. You seem to be vastly better on both.

1:01:34

You seem to be vastly better on both.

1:01:37

You're cheaper and you're delivering better results as I understand it.

1:01:42

um how are they still in business?

1:01:46

>> Um I I think what we realize is that this space does move you know this is not the fastest moving domain.

1:01:53

Um but I think that um what's I think interesting is the whole um um trend on uh agent commerce because I think that uh in a sense as more and more sellers and buyers are used to using agents uh it actually does change how things get purchased.

1:02:14

M >> um one of the biggest like um like um conventionalism of how commerce works is there's always these marketplaces that tax um all these sellers because they are able to get you customers.

1:02:31

They give you the best shopping experience, >> right?

1:02:33

>> Um and that's the same for wholesale too.

1:02:35

Um there are these wholesale marketplaces that charge um you know 20 25% commissions on top of their wholesale price which is already a discount of of their products.

1:02:45

Um and it's because it is a way easier way shopping experience for their wholesale buyers.

1:02:54

Um, and that makes sense even as a shopper.

1:02:57

Like I I it's a lot easier for me to just order things on Amazon than to um crawl through hundred different websites um and try to track what the lowest price is.

1:03:07

But then in the age of like agent of commerce, >> agents can agents can actually go through and compare prices on 200 different websites.

1:03:15

different websites. And I think that's why there is actually a world where more and more brands will want to sell a lot more direct whether it's retail customers or wholesale customers and that's why we actually launched um um our storefront um products last week and

1:03:31

we actually are offering that for free and um these software vendors used to charge you know hundreds and thousands of dollars for just their wholesale portal because um brands that are able to do wholesale had that budget to to purchase just expensive software. Um but

1:03:46

purchase just expensive software. Um but what we are seeing is actually more and more brands more or more small mid-Siz brands would want to set up their direct wholesale channel and buyers also would are going to be able to uh buy from lots of um separate scattered um direct

1:04:03

portals because um agents are able to bundle that for the human buyers >> and I I've thought that the age of the agentic uh buying and selling would potentially be very deflationary because uh the previous market like was very inefficient um and you know uh agents don't get tired they they don't need a coffee break etc. Um, but what what do you

1:04:35

Um, but what what do you think about like big brands?

1:04:38

We mentioned Amazon, right?

1:04:40

They've turned off access to the agents.

1:04:42

I think that that ultimately is not going to be a winning proposition. Mhm.

1:04:50

>> Um, and my guess is I'd be interested in your point of view, but that Amazon itself will have its own uh group of agents, but I don't know how much the consumer is going to trust that those agents are going to actually find them either the best product or the best price or whatever.

1:05:08

How do you see this whole thing unfolding?

1:05:11

This is kind of a broader question than just your specific company. Mhm.

1:05:17

So it's a question basically uh h how would um these larger like marketplaces like respond to this and and with that >> with that and and but also is there an opportunity for a new marketplace >> that caters directly to agents for example. >> Yeah.

1:05:38

Uh that is definitely a possibility but I think that um these marketplaces um so require both sides to be signed on to that platform um is the analogy would be um would you want to only crawl through like Wikipedia articles or Reddit articles or would you want to get information from any sources on the internet?

1:06:06

I think that's the analogy here.

1:06:07

And the reason why even >> I like that one. No, that's really good.

1:06:12

>> Maybe I should be using that more.

1:06:14

But uh but yeah, basically uh the reason why I mean when he first started, we thought like I mean there are these big wholesale marketplaces and like would it make sense for these uh brands to set up their own wholesale portal?

1:06:24

Uh the truth is there are always buyers that are not on those marketplaces, right?

1:06:30

and that you still want to do business with them and that's why you always need a direct channel and um agents even make it easier for the buyers to find um and keep buying um and building relationship with these small midsize brands under direct channel as well.

1:06:47

So that I I um I do believe in in that direction.

1:06:50

Um and in a sense that actually this intermediates uh the the marketplaces that were able to build that um w garden uh because of uh the limitation of human attention uh which is now gone with AIDS.

1:07:08

And I mean it becomes almost a philosophical question but uh it seems to me that your insight is absolutely correct.

1:07:20

Who who wants to just look for information on Wikipedia?

1:07:25

>> Nobody I don't I want to be able to look as broadly as possible.

1:07:28

Uh but then what there seems to be if like we take this argument and continue advancing it like what's going to happen to advertising, right?

1:07:42

Is it going to become very bespoke in terms of like highly targeted to a specific thing?

1:07:49

Uh is it going to go broad? Right.

1:07:52

Um and what what happens to like physical locations? What do you think?

1:08:02

>> H um because like I I I I'm not a mall person.

1:08:07

Uh but uh I was talking to a friend and they said it kind of like hey I went to a mall the other day and it was like this really why?

1:08:21

But what they said was like it was a ghost town there. There was nobody there.

1:08:29

um more of that, less of that, a resurgence of no, damn it, I want to go and go store to store and do it the super inefficient way.

1:08:39

M >> um I think that uh I think it's actually like um I want to take a step back and actually kind of label that as more of a like sales and marketing problem that like a lot of businesses face with because channel which sales channel which marketing channel is has the best um alpha does change over time.

1:09:02

uh in a sense like brands um were affected by the direct to consumer um which was based on social media marketing being saturated uh and that actually had forced a lot of these brands to change their business model.

1:09:21

Um I think what's important for these uh small mid-size brands is to be less dependent on specific channels and be able to adapt to um the different changes on purchase behaviors uh and what and sales channels.

1:09:34

U for example like we keep seeing fluctuating like um predictions on oh would people buy more from malls and and big box stores or would they go back to local?

1:09:45

It actually if you look at the headlines it it literally changes back and forth every two years.

1:09:52

Um but I think what's important is for brands to be um and this is where like if you're running um this process inhouse um there's one person who's managing direct to consumer social ads and wholesale email campaigns.

1:10:09

We actually what what he saw was you would in like November uh you would start seeing these brands moving their whole flow managers to become customer support for their Shopify website because they get spike in their traffic.

1:10:24

Um so basically because of lack of resources they're forced to sacrifice and give up certain channels depending on how things um go.

1:10:32

Um and I think what um like where where we can come in and help is basically uh we build out their um whole department that is agnostic to these different channels for them to be able to experiment more and find the best um uh matching say sales channel or marketing channel.

1:10:50

Do do you think that there's an opportunity for um an aggregator like when I was growing up there was a magazine called Consumer Reports, right?

1:11:03

>> And what they would do is they would test all of the washing machines or cars or whatever and then they would say, you know, this one is the absolute best.

1:11:14

This one is the best value, right?

1:11:14

So, it's not as good as this top one, but for what you're paying, this is the one you should do.

1:11:24

Given the way the world is going, right?

1:11:27

And like, uh, we're thinking about, here's a real example.

1:11:30

We're thinking about getting a ping pong table.

1:11:32

Uh, because my grandson is very good at it.

1:11:37

I used to be very good at it.

1:11:37

I'd love to play with him.

1:11:39

And so I had one of my agents go and look for ping pong tables.

1:11:47

Do you know how many it came back with?

1:11:50

>> That like if you didn't specify, >> but then but then so I specifically asked it. >> Uhhuh. >> Okay.

1:11:56

Um look at RA rating systems, look at customer uh uh you know uh reviews, etc.

1:12:08

and and it does seem to me that there is no single trusted source or multiple if you will.

1:12:16

>> Is that going to be a thing?

1:12:16

Because like there's going to be with agents having the ability to find every single ping pong table for this particular size.

1:12:26

>> Uh you're going to have to have a sorting mechanism uh based on price, based on quality, based on a variety of these things. Mhm. >> Yeah.

1:12:35

I think that uh there'll definitely be like a need for like kind of verifying um like the source of of like what's information is most importance um for for purchase like for for any buyers.

1:12:48

Um but then the truth is actually um a lot of the brands are not like even like step like they're even like you know step behind on that problem.

1:12:58

And what what happens is like if you don't have any uh pro information um on your website that is agent friendly um then you get um like what what wins is like louder blogs or you know Reddit articles that are that mentions your brand.

1:13:19

Um we even saw how like you know pricing for our um like platform was completely wrong on like Google AI mode because uh we just didn't clarify that on all other websites.

1:13:33

So and then there just like bloss mention those and those tend to win over your actual source of of data.

1:13:39

So this actually does um you know make it so that like it's it's a lot more important for brands to kind of control like what they sell, how they sell in our storefront.

1:13:49

So like there's a big section on the pricing policies uh and all the brand information that brands get to like directly control because um in these like marketplace entries is there a limitation of like how much story that you can tell and all the information that you can actually put in for your uh products and your your full catalog.

1:14:08

>> And how many of your brands use dynamic pricing?

1:14:12

>> Um so that's actually what what um makes wholesale interesting.

1:14:15

Um, for DTOC, not not a lot of brands use dynamic pricing.

1:14:20

Uh, it's it's hard to maintain.

1:14:20

It's it's hard to get it right.

1:14:21

Um, but for wholesale, the whole industry is basically built on dynamic pricing depending on the strategic uh importance of this like retailer like even though it's a very small store is a very like it has a very high uh social media presence um or it's it has a potential to break into that entire region, they would do a larger wholesale discount for those um buyers.

1:14:43

Um same for like net terms.

1:14:46

Uh net terms essentially like um depending on how healthy how big that um business is they are willing to take on more risk and give them longer net terms.

1:14:56

Um so what we came to realize is actually um wholesale ordering um pricing needs a lot of business context.

1:15:06

Um so when we first thought u like two years ago like we we thought why would he even build ordering platform because isn't that already solved but for wholesale the pricing was a hard part um and it makes so much sense for that data to be right next to the sales data in their CRM um so that's how we u uh thought that we had like a reason to build um storefronts uh and essentially how can he right now it is still being done in a manual way.

1:15:35

Uh we built the software infrastructure that allows brands to um specify custom discounts, custom pricing for wholesale buyers, >> but uh we're moving to a world where basically we will have um agents and be able to be a lot more prescriptive about okay given this uh retailer's strategic value or their um their health um you should be giving, you know, XYZ in terms of pricing and discounts and um net terms um for their um host orders.

1:16:07

>> And another thing that I wonder about is again uh agents don't have any of the problems that humans have.

1:16:13

We need to sleep, we need to eat, we get cranky, we have bad moods, we get exuberant, we get overly excited, we do all of these things and all of these things are basically because of our human OS which is mostly emotionally driven. Mhm.

1:16:32

>> Um and emotions probably drive a lot of purchase decisions as well.

1:16:39

>> Uh but in a world where it's agents, right, like how how many things that are currently would be considered a premium product become a commodity? Mhm.

1:16:52

Um I I think that actually uh it will um I always like use the word like amplifier a lot for when explaining agents um and same for codings and for buying um and I think it does amplify the the preferences that people have and that's also true for buyers um making purchase decisions.

1:17:10

So, um I think that for the more even for wholesale buyers, there are the more like data driven ones that look through um the sell through rates uh and and they they would base their purchase behaviors on that.

1:17:26

But they're also um buyers that are more um it's more important for for products to fit their overall retailer retailers um overall vibe um and um the types of products that they want to like overall atmosphere of that that store and I think that essentially just amplify that behavior.

1:17:46

So I I actually don't think that um like the premium cross will actually be like that slash into more of a commodity.

1:17:52

Um because if that was true, I think that uh you would live in a world where um there would actually be less brands uh and we would actually prefer to buy more of you know um Amazon basics because everything or Kirkland products because that's essentially what people want.

1:18:09

people want. But I think that um there are always sk uh products that um are like that in the equilibrium state becomes a commodity and there are um products that require uh brands or people prefer to be more branded um and

1:18:27

I think it'll just amplify like both sides um for the the buying behaviors >> and and do you think that we will ever get to a point where the agents and the and the stack that you've built literally are able to incorporate human emotional reasons for buying. Right. I I I have Right.

1:18:48

I I I have long believed >> that most decisions are made emotionally and then they are papered over with rational reasons for why you did it. Right?

1:19:02

Like I in in when I was a kid, they had these infomercials on TV at night and I I used to love watching them just because of the psychology of it, right, more than anything else.

1:19:18

>> Uh and you could see that they were literally, you know, selling purely on emotions, right? Mhm.

1:19:26

>> Um I I think it would be really interesting if the agents could in some way quantify that or am I just too much of a quant?

1:19:39

>> So I actually did double major in computer science and psychology, but it's that's a still a tough Yeah, I don't know the right answer for this question.

1:19:46

Um, but I I actually do think that like if I I still think that's true and uh because um if that was not the case, um sales or marketing would not matter at all.

1:19:59

Um and the fact that depending on how you change a subject line, how you change um how you like explain your product in our brands email campaigns, that actually yields different results.

1:20:13

that is a proof that depending on how you um explain and how how you trigger the different emotional reactions for these buyers, it does make a difference.

1:20:24

So um I think what we're helping is trying to make that into a more of a datadriven way, but essentially I think that is still going to be true um on how buyers respond to these different uh messaging.

1:20:39

I I think that uh one of the things that I've given a lot of thought to is we we are highly suggestible creatures we humans and I think that uh especially the newest frontier models.

1:20:52

I I've I've been having every model since the beginning >> and when they called it machine learning as opposed to AI or or what does Trump want to call it? Uh super intelligence.

1:21:06

>> I I don't think that one's going to work.

1:21:07

Um but um I think that they are going to get really good at persuasion, right?

1:21:17

Like the the classic text on it is Chelini's influence.

1:21:21

I don't know whether you've read that or not.

1:21:25

not. Um but we we are um in many respects highly suggestible and um I I I can see a future where you just have the AI AB test out infinitum >> and yeah of course some of it's going to be like that was just a fluke that's an outlier it doesn't actually work but

1:21:52

they'll be able to figure that out too >> and And and I can also envision a future where people just get so used to their agents buying necessities or basics or things like that that that bleeds into what we currently think of as premium >> uh type uh products or services. Um

1:22:12

Um which which way do you see that going?

1:22:27

I'm I'm I'm relying on your debate.

1:22:27

Uh >> yeah, I don't think I'm not sure if I like fully got got the question.

1:22:32

So, what what are the two two camps here?

1:22:35

>> The the two camps are um the the latest Frontier models are demonstraably superior >> to even those of six months ago. >> Right. Right.

1:22:46

Um, and one of the things that I always uh test them on are persuasion techniques.

1:22:51

They're getting really really good.

1:22:57

>> And I could envision a uh a future where let's say I'm trying to sell um you some premium protein powder, >> right?

1:23:12

And so I have to do all of the research that says we're the best and here's why we're the best.

1:23:19

These independent labs, blah blah blah.

1:23:21

But I could also see having the models just a b test different persuasion techniques >> till they get to the one where they're the person's just smashing the buy button, right?

1:23:34

I need this because it's going to solve all my problems. Right?

1:23:39

Like as I mentioned earlier, I think a lot of our choices are emotional and generally people buy things to solve a pain or to achieve some hoped for outcome in terms of prestige or their desiraability or their attractiveness or whatever. Mhm.

1:24:01

>> And and so I could see one where the models just continually learn >> from their interactions with we humans >> till they get to the point where like they're just getting really really good at persuasion.

1:24:15

But I can equally see people like buying basics that they don't really care too much about.

1:24:21

I guess we used to call these consumer staples, right?

1:24:25

Um and then that bleeding into just like everything.

1:24:28

I'll just let I'll just let the agent >> get that for me.

1:24:32

Which which of those paths do you think is more likely? >> I see.

1:24:37

Um basically I think there's like more like there are inherently differentiated goods that requires persuasion.

1:24:51

Um and then there's commodities or staples that are um that I think there is like a right answer.

1:25:00

What is the cheapest toilet paper?

1:25:03

And then you you can get a like deterministic answer whereas like what is the best um like um couch for our apartments there's there's no like clear answer to that which I think in the the first type of products um there are going to be persuasions involved.

1:25:22

Um on the second uh side though I think that um those u are going to be uh a lot easier for agents to go straight to the answer and people to be a lot more okay with just just approving uh whichever cheapest uh product they bought for those product.

1:25:42

So basically my my answer is I think it will depend on the product category.

1:25:46

there always going to be what we'll call you know luxury goods or branded goods um that uh where there's a lot more taste involved um and that I think is um still um there are going to be um human input that that is needed for both um on the persuasion techniques but also on the other side of purchase behaviors and I

1:26:10

think al but then on the other side for for less differentiated goods I think it's I I I think we'll be more on the the the latter whereas um like agents can be actually autopiloting and and going straight sort of the the best answers >> and and then the obvious question also becomes h how do you hack the agent? >> Are you talking about the seller side or

1:26:32

>> Are you talking about the seller side or buyer side? >> Seller side. >> Seller side.

1:26:37

Um so yeah I I think that um so most of the brands that we work with are um these are mostly the brands that are I mean they're called a brand for a reason they they um there are they have a niche angle either in terms of their audience or type of values that they represent.

1:26:53

Uh and that's and these are uh important parts even when we think about their sales and marketing strategy.

1:26:59

Um so um the the part about how like the these agents are doing AB testing on like what um what's the best strategy that's literally what's happening under the hood for our like lead generation services because basically um we can keep figuring out increase the temperature try different tactics and see which one land is better.

1:27:22

So, um I'm a huge fan of uh Bob Persig's book Zen and the Odor Motorcycle Maintenance.

1:27:28

Um, and he has a story in there that has stuck with me and it it's he's riding he rides motorcycles obviously and he's riding with a friend who is driving a BMW motorcycle and he's very proud of the fact that he has a BMW um and something goes wrong with it and the guy is heartbroken because there isn't a BMW authorized service center uh for you know 500 miles.

1:27:58

And what's he going to do?

1:28:01

And Persig takes a soda can top, takes the little uh pull uh circle out, fashions it, and puts it on the guy's motorcycle fixing it. Right.

1:28:16

The guy though, rather than being thankful, is outraged and he's like, "How dare you take a soda top and put it on my, you know, pristine BMW?"

1:28:26

I I I wonder there's also a a thesis of happiness where they ask the question, what would you do if you woke up tomorrow and you were the last human being on the planet?

1:28:46

There hasn't been any cataclysmic problem.

1:28:48

There weren't there wasn't a war or anything.

1:28:50

It's just literally all of the other humans disappeared. Everything is as it was. So what would you do?

1:29:00

And and when they interview people about this question in the beginning, many say, well, you know, I'd go to the Louv and take the Mona Lisa and put it in the palace and I would live in the palace and I would drive the fanciest sports car.

1:29:14

But then as they continued the questioning, they found that after a while, most people started saying, "Well, actually, you know, if I really was the last human, I'd probably live in a place that was very easy for me to maintain.

1:29:32

I probably would only wear really comfortable clothes.

1:29:37

I really wouldn't care what I drove."

1:29:40

And and basically it was the result was many of the things that we buy or desire are to impress other people, right?

1:29:52

I mean it's the whole story of the luxury goods market and and do do you see agents having any effect on that sort of thing or is am am I just being too philosophical?

1:30:12

I mean to be honest my my mind when I was thinking about like you know when I'm the last person uh there my mind went straight to there are some like Slack channels in our team where there's just agents and just me right or the group chats on on rockbot where there's there's four agents and only only person there and just how do I talk there how what's my behavior there that my mind went straight to that point.

1:30:40

So uh >> well let's let's answer that question.

1:30:43

That's a much more interesting question.

1:30:46

Do are you a different person when you are just interacting with agents?

1:30:51

>> Um I think that is true.

1:30:51

I feel like um like if like just being in those group chats where I name all my Grog bots as you know designer, engineer, product manager and like I'm just talk um I yeah definitely like how you talk becomes very very direct.

1:31:09

Um, no like you know uh words >> no no no $5 words to make yourself sound smart >> and definitely you know embarrassing but less gratitude for all the work that we've done. So that is that is true.

1:31:26

But then if I think about it actually um because I'm still reviewing all all the like some of the the the outputs that agents produce like uh I am still um affected by how they how the agents phrase the the work that they've done.

1:31:46

Um which essentially is analogous to um say branding or persuasion techniques.

1:31:53

Um, but I I think the biggest change for me is like how I respond back.

1:31:56

It's very direct, very straightforward points.

1:31:59

Um, and um, and yeah, I that's the biggest biggest difference.

1:32:08

>> Um, I I I think it's that actually that could be an entirely different podcast.

1:32:14

Uh, because, you know, I I'm a huge fan of the literary fiction author Sebastian Bry.

1:32:21

Um he's an Irish guy and a lot of his books are based on old family stories of his family.

1:32:26

Um, and and I finished uh the third book in his McNelte series uh called A Temporary Gentleman and I wanted to talk about it and like all of my friends were either otherwise engaged or not around >> and so I'm just like, you know what, I'm just going to talk to my AI agent about this.

1:32:51

and we have a pretty uh cutting edge uh uh group of agents and I actually had like an amazing conversation uh and and because at first I I I said, "Hey, find the earliest reviews of this book because I have a question about this, this, and this, right?"

1:33:11

And it did a great job of finding the old reviews.

1:33:15

I think it was originally published in 2012.

1:33:17

Um, but then I said, "Well, what do you think?"

1:33:20

And like literally all of the training data I was talking to a PhD in literary fiction.

1:33:29

>> Uh, and I'm like, "Wow, that's a really good point."

1:33:33

>> Um, and and so I'm I'm absolutely fascinated by how just society in general is going to evolve.

1:33:44

um and and and how marketing, how brands, how all of that I I I obviously can't prophesize the future.

1:33:53

I have ideas, but it it it definitely I think is going to change the way that people do a lot of things.

1:34:03

Um do do you think that um these smaller brands um can survive without you guys?

1:34:15

>> Like meaning um yeah I want to get in I want to become a wholesale brand as well.

1:34:22

I'm going to this agency or this marketplace like how how do they not just get totally obliterated? >> Yeah.

1:34:32

I mean, I think that uh like we got to a point where even uh I was trying to see if I can launch like a you know, a brand for fun.

1:34:41

Um and run I got my fun like site hustle and uh using Overjoy.

1:34:48

I mean I have I'm not like a uh for to be a salesperson.

1:34:52

I'm not I don't know the wholesale space uh that well uh outside of like how we before working on Overjoy.

1:34:59

Um and but then yeah we're able to get like um interested buyers through our our platforms.

1:35:06

I I feel like it really um a lot of brand founders some of them have sales background but then a lot of them are actually they are a lot more passionate about their their products uh and getting that right.

1:35:19

and getting that right. So the vision that often I have is like can we actually make uh help them um be attracted away from all the less differentiated um u work on the on on sales and back office um so that they can uh be a lot more focused on product building brand building um and I think that's basically like what we are unlocking for these brands a lot of

1:35:44

these brands are able to run their sales wholesale process because of us um and be able to have a direct sales channel because of us and um I think they will be a lot more expensive, a lot harder for them to um have a profitable even though experiments to unlock that channel um because how you start that is so expensive >> and and what do you and Alex hope for? What's

1:36:11

What's your what what uh if you could have your dream outcome, >> what is that?

1:36:18

Yeah, I think um the biggest thing is can we actually have some of those smallest brands that we have at our customers be able to scale even further without having to worry about how do we keep um by by keep removing those bottlenecks as they grow out this channel.

1:36:35

So we start we started from getting their first interested buyers.

1:36:39

Then we moved on to making them um get to the first opening order and then now become make them become repeat customers.

1:36:46

And now they're running new problems on how do I deal with um pricing?

1:36:52

How do I go into now big box stores?

1:36:54

All these new problems that actually go along the way.

1:36:55

Can you keep removing the bottlenecks um so that they can still scale in a very lean way?

1:37:02

That's basically uh what we're trying to achieve.

1:37:04

and and uh just on big box stores like I am the worst person.

1:37:08

I'm not a shopper at all.

1:37:10

I I don't go to big box stores. I don't do any of that.

1:37:18

>> Do they survive things?

1:37:18

The opportunity set for people who, you know, were a two or three person operation can suddenly sell to the entire world.

1:37:29

uh agents like I'm absolutely fascinated by where all of this goes.

1:37:36

>> Um and so I I ask people who are in the trenches what they think as well. itself. >> Yeah.

1:37:42

Um I mean I I there are some like insane problems that we do encounter as we look at brands work working with big box stores like it's um I do think that there's an advantage of kind of coming from outside of domain and kind of applying first principles uh on all the problems that we face because we're looking at how these brands sell to box stores.

1:38:02

They come in um huge quantities.

1:38:06

they often have net terms that where they don't immediately get get paid.

1:38:11

they need to first deal with how to source that you know way bigger order size for these stores and if they don't fulfill it in time uh through EDI they get punished uh there's also like a big cost for for these brands to set up EDI to be able to talk to these order system of these big box stores and like for a lot of these small like founders they are scared to even enter that space um because of that >> and Then what happens is now once you

1:38:43

are able to start selling to these big box stores because they need to focus they tend to give up the independence channel that actually um they they spend so much time nurturing and scaling and then only when they become big enough

1:38:56

they start seeing the value of these small retailers across country this like a longtail independence and then they start to build the sales process again that's been a lot of stories that we see in our brands. So essentially like what

1:39:09

in our brands. So essentially like what you're doing today is that independent channel um because we talked to these brand founders they're like okay I'm like chasing deals in Starbucks I'm chasing deals with um Target and that and the moment they start that they the whole profitable like sale channel all

1:39:27

for independence they just give and that is absolutely insane like they they should not do that um so we're basically solving that problem for these brands so they don't give off that sales channel and then our goal is the people to keep making other channels as predictable and easy to maintain as what we've already done for their local independent shell. >> All right, June. Uh I think that uh you >> All right, June.

1:39:46

Uh I think that uh you guys have uh done a a ridiculously brilliant job.

1:39:54

Um I love the way that you were like, "Oh, wait a minute.

1:39:57

This whole service thing over here makes a lot more sense."

1:40:02

Um, if you're familiar with the podcast, you know that the final question I I give to you is I make you emperor of the world. You can't kill anyone.

1:40:14

You can't put anyone in a re-education camp.

1:40:16

But what you can do is I'm going to hand you a magical microphone.

1:40:20

And you could say two things into it that is going to incept the entire population of Earth.

1:40:27

They're going to wake up whenever their next morning is.

1:40:31

And the two things that you say, they're going to think they thought up or had a dream about or whatever, and they're going to resolve. You know what?

1:40:40

Unlike all the other times, these two ideas are two that I'm really going to work on and and try to habituate in myself.

1:40:48

What two things would you be incepting in the world's population?

1:40:51

Um I think my answer to that would be uh one is be ambitious and then two be uh two be grateful.

1:41:02

Um that's how I've pictured um how my life would uh how I want my life to go.

1:41:08

Uh I'm going to spend a good chunk of first chapter of my life on being doing the most ambitious things.

1:41:14

Um but the eventually um I think it it's important to be uh to to transition into a lot more gratitude mode uh and be grateful for um everything's everything that kind of happened to you and everything that you you were able to um achieve.

1:41:31

Um, one thing that I really like in our team even as we are growing really fast is um, every Friday we have um, a Friday happy hour and we do um, shout outs and we share all the grateful things and all all the you know we throw shout outs at everyone um, for um, you know 15 minutes and that is always a highlight of my week.

1:41:55

Um, and I think it's important to kind of balance those two.

1:41:58

Uh because it's easy to be overoptimizing for for for one of them.

1:42:02

So, uh, being ambitious and being grateful that those are going to be my >> I I think both of those are great, especially the gratitude one.

1:42:08

Um, I think that people really underestimate uh how much they can change their own life, but also the lives of others, like your shoutouts at your happy hour.

1:42:25

Um, being grateful just keeps your mind in a whole different place.

1:42:29

Like I am ridiculously grateful for everything in my life and I'm ridiculously grateful that I know people like you and can invest and and watch you grow and do things.

1:42:43

But also, I'm just incredibly grateful that I'm alive at this juncture in human history because I think the next 10 years are going to be a bit uh tumultuous to say the least, but they're going to be very very interesting uh because of companies and and people like you and Alex.

1:43:03

June, thank you so much for being on Infinite Loops. >> Thanks so much.