0:09
Hello everyone, welcome back to semi analysis weekly.
Hello everyone, welcome back to semi analysis weekly.
On this episode, we talking everything uh data center moratoriums and the US midterms election that is happening today while we record it.
If you are listening to this after the results, well, you know what we're about to say, I guess.
But, uh, we're going to dig into the impact of this election in the US midterms and, uh, everything it has to do with data center.
So, with me, I've got Maya, Wayne, and Jeremy.
And guys, let's uh let's dig in specifically uh let's start with just what analysis you guys did high level context and my maybe specifically what has changed since you were last on talking about the piece in September um where you educated a lot of people about the realities of the mortoriiums at that time. >> Sure.
So this article's core argument is that the 2027 data center pipeline is largely uh locked in, but that the 2028 is not because much of that capacity still needs approvals and permits uh in states where the midterms could bring pauses or tougher rules.
So for 2027, there's roughly 34 of the capacity uh that's due to come online uh for the top 20 states and that's already under construction.
So today's midterms um the results are not going to stop it.
So that's why we're still comfortable with the the 50 plus gigawatt um gigawatt global year we laid out a few weeks ago.
and the election could change the rules around how data center campuses are built.
But the 2027 pipeline uh has a big head start already and 2028 uh is the actually the year that uh that is important to watch and we make that argument in in our article.
Our model has about 62 gawatts of US editions that year and most of it isn't under construction as opposed to 2027.
So it's mostly sitting in states that are voting for uh a governor in the midterms.
So, you've got all of these projects uh waiting on permits, power and and and con construction schedules um while policies are being negotiated and and potentially rewritten.
Uh and so the single biggest risk I would say isn't like a single candidate.
uh because in many cases both parties and and candidates want developers to accept stricter terms.
In the case of uh Texas for example, it's a freeze uh that already exists.
So, Texas stopped issuing TCAQ permits uh to data center projects at the end of September on top of an aircott uh interconnection audit that started in August.
And Texas alone is close to 30% of US editions in 2028.
So, a few months of of lost time on that um on on that one on that one state on that one market.
uh could move the national number.
But the real difference is whether the the um the campuses the projects can meet the the terms and keep building and we have to wait and see what what the state uh does um and and and who gets elected.
So what's changed since uh September?
So in September in September we said that uh the moratoriums weren't actually killing the buildouts and that uh broad conclusion has has held.
Um in September we looked at roughly 20 gawatt sitting inside local restrictions and we estimated that only about uh 1.
5 gawatt was actually uh delayed and that's still true.
And some of the two biggest things that have changed is first Texas.
Um so as I said at the end of September, Abbott um uh imposed this freeze on TCQ permits for data center projects uh on top of the aircot interconnection Q audit uh that began uh in August and that pulls on-site power into the hold.
So in September we thought um that the bring your own power was the escape route uh but it isn't anymore.
And then another thing that has changed is that uh candidates have moved of the 20 nominees that we looked at in the top uh states uh in the govern the there 10 governor's races and nine want a pause on new construction and the other 11 want conditions.
Um and the split is even is about even by party.
Can you >> and I can talk a bit more about like the difference between pauses or moratoriums and conditions and what that would >> Yeah, I think.
>> Yeah, that'd be helpful.
I've got on screen the table showing that this is bipartisan.
There's Democrats and Republicans that are in favor of pauses or conditions.
So maybe you can define what a pause is versus a condition. >> Sure.
So by pause we essentially mean uh a moratorum uh which is a a halt on the processing and issuing of permits at different levels.
It could be a building permit, an air permit, uh a zoning uh halt for example.
Um and the difference matters because it's the difference between a projects between a project that's uh more expensive and in the case of conditions and a projects and a project that gets stuck uh because conditions make a project more expensive and a pause makes it uh can delay it.
So if new conditions are put in place, uh a developer can fund the grid update, they can redesign the cooling, uh they can sign the the community agreement, and they can keep going.
It might be slightly slower and and costlier, but uh it has a plan to uh to approval.
And we also saw a lot of that coming anyway like the water use studies, uh developers offering household bill credits to cover the infrastructure that they add.
Uh also AWS and Google dropping NDAs and dis being more transparent in their process.
But a pause is different because the work just can't proceed for projects that would don't have all of the permits in hand. >> Makes sense.
I think this map uh tells the story here, right?
Like if we look at 2028, um it's pretty clear that it's not everywhere in the US, but these are the big states where we're tracking the biggest additions of capacity in 2028.
most cases where um people have this in their backyard for example.
Um can you talk about you know like maybe dig in on Texas specifically a bit and just say what is the real difference between what's going on right now in 2027 versus what's going on in 2028 when you look at the difference between candidates like Greg Abbott and Gina Ha Josea here. >> Sure.
So in the map that you showed, so we looked at different scenarios.
We looked at this is the number one where the the states where it's still uh a tossup or it it we would win.
Uh this is the scenario where the pro- mortorium candidate wins.
And so you can see here that 30.
3 gawatts of planned 2028 capacity uh could potentially be at risk.
Uh of course that's not the capacity uh we're not saying that this could be the capacity that's delayed.
It's just the capacity that is exposed uh the capacity that is planned for 2028 in those states.
Um and then we looked at the second scenario.
Uh if you scroll if you scroll to the next uh map, right?
This is where the conditions only uh candidates would win.
And here the gigawatt of plant capacity that are exposed goes down to 5. 7.
Um and then looking at the polls which is the third map.
So this is the most likely scenario of what is to happen.
We see that it's not that uh as dramatic as the first map shows because uh only 5.
7 GW of plan 2028 capacity um is most likely to be at risk. Makes >> sense.
So when we look at like the potential outcomes here, one thing that strikes me, Wayne, maybe I can bring you in on this, is like the bipartisan nature of this.
So when you were looking into some of these uh local races or any of the local politics, I think I was particularly surprised to find that this doesn't cut across party lines about whether people are in favor of conditions versus a full-on moratorum. >> Right?
You know, when I when I was like look researching this, right, I thought, oh, probably Democrats are all on one side, maybe they want to pause, Republicans just want conditions.
But it turns out that's not the case at all.
And I think a part of it is just because there's such a huge anti-data center backlash that it doesn't matter if you're Republican or Democrat.
Uh if you're an ordinary resident and the data center is being built by you, it's going to uh upset you either way, right?
I mean, there's a lot of anxiety over AI taking people's jobs.
There's lots of misinformation out there about how much water they use or how much electricity they use or whether they're going to raise your your tax bills or your power bills.
And so I think that this is something that both Democrats and Republicans have kind of like tapped into uh in their campaigns.
And so, you know, what we're seeing is that it doesn't really matter if you're Republican or Democrat.
You know, some people um you know, it used to be that you know, states wanted the economic development.
They wanted the investment, right? Right.
They had all these tax rebates and tax incentives to bring data centers in and now it seems like all that's kind of going away um regardless of whether what part of you are on. >> Makes sense. Exactly.
>> Jeremy, what's your what's your take? Oh yeah, sorry.
My >> No, I just wanted Jeremy, you can go ahead.
Uh but I just wanted to give an example of Texas or another state where it's actually most states where um as Wayne said both candidates are actually in favor of tougher conditions uh if not moratorum at least tougher conditions around building campuses in their states. >> Makes sense. Yeah.
What's your take >> talking to people themselves?
No, I mean look like the the global conditions have like change changed so much, right?
Because a few years ago the let's call it the supply demand balance was so different uh where counties would do a big would offer big tax breaks would try as hard as they can to attract data center developers.
And that that actually kind of makes sense because if you look at the data center, it's this big warehouse.
You know, it's not that large of a construction project.
It consumes energy, consumes water, but not as much as other heavy industrial use cases, but the value of the building is really large, right?
Because the data center itself is expensive and the servers inside are even more expensive.
Sort of the ratio of like project value to like project size and sort of industrial scale is is quite interesting and one of the highest I think in terms of value per per sort of industrial footprint, let's say.
Um, and so as long as these data centers, I guess just there weren't that many.
So, but things were overall overall fine and people wanted them in the territory and so you would offer a tax breaks.
Now there's so many of them and [laughter] they're becoming so large that it's becoming complicated and obviously they have a few um issues.
They can make a lot of noise.
noise. uh the the country especially in some states have more and more water issues and uh there's a bunch of data centers in the past that would not really look at water as as an issue and so they would have these openloop uh cooling systems that would be very
energy efficient but water inefficient and so as as you go from just the the scale of like a few gigawatts built per year to in 2027 in the US 40 gawatt so we're effectively at something like 10 to 20x uh the size of the annual buildout in something like 5 years uh everything is different. Uh there's
Uh there's obviously so many of them and because the because of the supply constraints that we have now the balance of powers has dramatically changed, right?
And so it's like we don't necessarily want them now.
Uh but if they comp they got to do things right.
Um and they they're they're also more and more valuable.
GPUs are much more valuable per megawatt or per acre or per square feet.
And so you can you can effectively make them pay a lot of money, right?
>> [laughter] >> I think I think uh capitalism is going to solve part of the problem where these guys should be able to pay materially sort of or let's say just cut less incentives and so pay much more to the local community uh contribute much more such a small percentage of project value.
Um so it makes total sense.
The the other thing is as you add more and more of of these data centers, that's mostly on the on the electricity side, but as they connect to the grid, they they kind of create a systemic risk, uh which is in Texas, uh what the grid is worried about.
Um it's kind of the opposite scenario of what we've seen in Spain a few years ago with renewables on the generation side where if they're unreliable and they there's sort of a fault it can trigger um a cascading effect where everything trips out and the grid goes dark for a few days.
Um you can have the same thing on the load side.
Uh it's it's nearly happened in Virginia already.
uh were because of a voltage dip on the grid.
Uh every single data center that triggered their UPS system, they all disconnected at once from the grid and you had one and a half gawatt of load disappearing.
Uh that scale that fast that can trigger a blackout for the grid.
Uh so there's actually a lot of things are very legit, which kind of makes sense and sort of justifies why this is bipartisan.
Um and so all of this I think is understandable.
understandable. there's a transition period uh where yes now you have to add equipment that's going to add a bit of cost to handle these uh sort of grid issues and make sure you're let's call it a good grid citizen as people like to say water of course now uh you realize that if you're taking water and there's
five other projects then obviously there's not going to be enough for uh for everyone so you got to be uh more water efficient everyone is doing that um and so my actually my expectations is it's gonna sound crazy but I think I think things could get better because everyone is sort of realizing Okay. Uh Uh yeah, it makes sense.
The way we sort of designed before was for a smaller scale and as we have so many of these data centers at the same time, we need to adapt the way we we do it.
Uh so it makes sense for for the country, right?
So u yeah, I I think data centers are going to become much better neighbors and that should hopefully make uh the buildout better.
Uh but I I would say that that heavily justifies why this is a bipartisan issue.
There are very legit concerns that uh data center developers need to adapt to.
Yeah, I just want to add um one of the things that surprised me was Ohio.
So Ohio had these incentives that they thought would cost them maybe 136 million a year to bring data centers into the state and last year those incentives cost them or two years ago those incentives mushroom to 555 million. Last year it was 1. 6 billion.
So they were leaving like that, you know, they couldn't conceive that they would be leaving 1.
6 billion on the table uh with these incentives.
And and that's why one of the things is a lot of these candidates, you know, are running to roll back all these incentives regardless if they're Democratic or Republican.
>> I mean, just to caveat this a little bit, I think it's pretty common to when you want to host like very large scale industrial projects because again, like a 1 gawatt data center, as we know, is a $50 billion project, just an insane amount of money.
It is pretty common to offer tax breaks, tax advantages.
So, it's not like data centers were the bad guys and this was like something crazy.
Now, I think it's pretty common.
Um so the one way to look at it uh is to say like hey we could have gotten that much more money.
Another way to look at it is to say like this is actually the the normal way but because we're in times of supply constraints now we can actually like have these guys contribute materially more and uh you know increase the welfare of everyone around which I think you know I think makes sense.
Everyone wants to build in the US.
It's one of the world's best countries to build data centers and so uh it makes sense to also make sure they can uh you know support the the local folks.
Um and you know I think we're starting to see more and more of that and a lot of data center developers are spending uh or are not accepting accepting tax breaks anymore or are just contributing more locally. >> Yeah.
But I guess one thing that I'm hearing you guys say is is kind of converting a single governor's race into the policy across the whole state.
And in practice, Maya, I think you've educated me many times that like this depends on city councils, county boards, board of supervisors, utility commissions, like local issues rather than stuff that's statewide.
So, let's say one of the states goes one direction or the other, how does that actually flow through to every single project when there could be so many across the whole state, across so many different counties?
So lo local government approvals do matter but it's going to be a project by on a project by project basis that will uh look at uh whether a local government is pro- data centers or not and they're also very respondent to the local community.
community. Um whereas at the state level it it's going to depend on different factors and here uh ahead of the midterms this is why we're looking at um what's happening at the state level and governors um have a lot of power here because they can move really fast they
can direct agencies to stop issuing permits like Abbott in Texas or also in Oregon uh codeex environmental permit hold Um whereas le leg legislatures we also looked at they can uh set the tax breaks they can pass law but they're slower to move. We haven't seen any
We haven't seen any moratoriums being adopted uh at the legislative level yet and we don't see this as a significant risk for the time being.
Um, so yeah, uh, in in in Texas, uh, going back also to what Jeremy said, um, I personally think that, uh, well, first of all, uh, Governor Abbott is the favored candidate.
Uh, so he's expected to win a fourth term, although the race has somewhat tightened.
And I think uh this is part of of the reason why he's kind of changed his rhetoric to being very pro- data centers uh to just in the past few months um issuing all of those uh directives and um m being clear on his stance um on on how developers should uh pay their own way, should respect uh the communities um etc.
Um but I think that after once he gets elected after the midterms the most likely scenario is that the restrictions will ease.
And uh one um meaningful um tell here is that all of those directives that he issued will just um expire on their own.
He doesn't have to reverse them.
Um so it's quite easy for him to um to let them uh slip on their own and um the permitting can then move forward.
uh in December >> or at the beginning of next year.
>> Maybe the other thing to dig into more is like functionally how it works.
You said all of these different directives and I was lumping all of this stuff in when I was reading the initial thing.
It was just like either pause or conditions, but there's actually a whole bunch of different political positions that can impact a data center.
you guys go through like a temporary pause or moratorum conditions, but also um candidates can favor, you know, a political position where you force people to pay their own grid costs or protect rateayers.
They can end tax executive.
They can have a position on water limits or reporting of water usage, bring your own on-site power, forced their uh community benefits, transparency or bans on the NDA, local control over state decision.
like I just listed off all of the different columns on this or rows on this uh table here.
Um is there a coherent position that cuts across all of these or is it just like a total mess across all of the different states?
Like is there anything everybody's in favor of or everybody's against or like what's the way to think of this?
I would say that um Democrats tend to lean towards a temporary pause, but it doesn't mean that if you're Democrat, you're going to advocate for a moratorum.
Um as you can see from the from the graph, it's quite bipartisan even for the moratoriums.
Um it it's actually very interesting to to see um how uh popular these new conditions whether it's pay your own grid uh end tax incentives bring your own power are uh popular across the political spectrum. >> Yeah.
People seem to be thinking these things through in an interesting way compared to other political positions.
like everybody's coming up with their own um sampling of different positions across all of the different stuff.
>> I think the Democrats lean toward, oh, we have to use union labor to build these data centers or operate them. That's a big one.
Republicans want to leave um control to the local communities.
Uh I guess that makes sense, you know, like state versus like top down versus, you know, bottom up.
uh and Democrats want more, you know, bans on NDAs.
I think it's not as important, you know, to Republicans.
So, that's sort of like uh where they're kind of split, but for every house conditions, electric energy, ends of tax incentives, I think they're very aligned. Makes sense.
So, do you think there's those specific positions?
You think those are kind of like no-brainers?
Those are going to go through across all of the states, but potentially they don't actually impact the buildout in 28 that much.
>> You think that's a reasonable conclusion?
>> I mean, look, to impact to impact the the 20 27 buildout, you need something that impacts uh like you need some item that projects already scheduled to be delivered in 2027 don't have.
And as we've been hammering a lot over the last few uh weeks, few months, um the R27 forecast, which is a I think on the very high side of estimates on the market, is is based on projects that are already under construction like the Shell is already under construction.
So in the vast majority of cases, they already have the construction permit, storm water, whatever uh whatever you want.
And most of them already have the air pollution permit.
pollution permit. Now, to be fair, I would say the single biggest uh downside risk uh that we have is probably uh Texas um based on our findings in in this in this article notably um and as we've said to our clients over the last few weeks and few months because uh some
projects that are under construction today where you see the shell being built that are already funded right so some of them have raised billions if not tens of billions of dollars to fund the DC um don't have the final air pollution permit yet u because historically timeline are are fairly short and so you
could sort of get away with this where in other states stop uh stuff takes longer to get approved and so it does not make sense to have this sort of more aggressive uh construction strategy and so there's a risk as Maya was saying earlier that uh if you followed what the Democrats are proposing in Texas uh the
pause could be extended until new laws are sort of approved uh that could extend towards perhaps mid 2027 and then the pause on approving new air pollution permits uh could be extended from like today the expectation is about December uh into middle of next year. Um and as
Um and as you don't have uh this final approval, you're not allowed to actually build a power plant.
Uh the data center you can and that's going to continue, but the power plants you won't.
And so you could actually see a bunch of shells in this scenario that are uh halfway built or mostly built but don't have uh the electricity to run because they they were not able to get the the permit effectively.
Um so that yeah that that's a scenario I would say not not our base case right now, but it's entirely possible.
So that's how 27 would be impacted.
Otherwise, most of it as we said is 28 and you know we go into that in great depth in our article on moratoriums which was published a few months ago where for example we we explained the impact of the statewide New York moratorium uh which is mostly a question of like 28 plus uh anything already under construction is permitted and is not impacted by the moratorium.
going back to the conditions um and taking Texas as the as the example.
Um so we can look at the two different scenarios.
Um so first Abbott so if he gets reelected uh what what would happen um would is that air would uh if everything goes to plan air files its audit report.
It's targeted beginning of uh December and then permitting can reopen with stricter requirements.
A restart around December is it's an interruption but most projects can absorb uh this inside their schedules. Abbott.
It is also uh campaigning around um the 2027 legislature ending data center incentives, putting cost protections in law, uh requiring projects to add electricity supply and tighten water efficiency and rules.
Uh so he also wants conditions to be implemented. his Democratic opponent.
Uh she's a more bearish case because she would keep a moratorum in place until the legislature uh passes certain protections.
Uh these protections are uh for example protecting household electricity and water bills.
uh an end to subsidies, a ban on NDAs, uh union labor, and we looked at the different scenarios and we estimated that given that the regular uh legislative session runs from January to May 2027, if uh approvals um go through that session, the pause would run about 8 months And if new rules take effect in late summer, it would be close to a year.
So that's five to nine extra month uh versus a December restart.
Um and campus uh campuses that are aiming for a 2027 delivery, that doesn't uh leave them much time to to uh to spare. >> Yeah.
So clearly this is the race you're watching most closely today, Maya, or are you watching others as well? >> Exactly.
I mean, we're watching it closely, but uh the polls all show that Abbott is projected to win. >> Makes sense. Yeah.
And I guess there's there's always a difference between what they're saying during the campaign versus what plays out in practice over the next number of months or years. I mean, um >> Exactly. the chart here. >> It's >> Yeah. Go.
>> No, I wanted to say I think it's important to flag that we also take all of the propositions uh from these candidates at face value in this article.
Um even though some of them um might uh it might be smarter to take them with a grain of salt. Right. >> Yeah. Yeah, makes sense.
I was going to say that Georgia seems to be a huge tossup, right?
Like the post, you know, both candidates are neck and neck and uh that, you know, uh Kesha Lance Bottoms, you know, she wants a temporary pause and Rick Jackson is is more for conditions.
>> Um yeah, but it's it's interesting just looking at this table that you guys made because so many of these um you know, positions are not stated.
So, not only is it a toss-up election where the candidates don't differ that much, you know, issue by issue, but neither of them have a stated position on ending tax incentives, for example.
That's like a that's that's a huge thing for a given project for, you know, a given company.
Let's assume there's some conditions and one of those conditions is ending the tax incentive.
That's probably like one of the biggest impacts to a data center project right there.
Um, then you can just go through issue by issue, race by race, and I think get really wrapped up in exactly what this means going forward.
>> Then there's always a question of like, you know, what is the most efficient way to deal with this?
Do you want to have a state that like imposes everything or do you want to delegate more towards sort of local authorities and like that that more decentralized model can can sometimes be faster?
Like for example, um, if we talk about power, like bring your own power.
Uh let's just imagine like if we just imagine and make it simple.
Imagine there's a law that says you must bring your own power.
Uh it's kind of a weird thing to say because it really like power is is can be very local.
Um and now even within a state you can have like different grids.
For example, in India you have PJM you have myo right which are function in different ways.
And so those have different rule and so it wouldn't really make sense for a state like that to say hey you must bring your own power right like hey if if there's a power available in this area then maybe you can take it if you want to go off-grid then obviously you're going to bring your own power because the way you do it.
So anyways all of those to say like uh decentralization also makes sense sometimes better to not you know control everything at the state level and and also some of these rules uh must must consider actual sort of local um you know local conditions. How about federal stuff?
There's two more years of uh Trump administration coming after this and the states obviously have their way of controlling things, but um look, this is bipartisan all the way up to the top where Trump has made pretty clear that he doesn't want uh you know price on the grid to increase.
That's that's one position.
So what else are you guys watching at the federal level after this happens?
Like let's say Democrats sweep and they take control of the House and the Senate. That mean >> Yeah.
So if Democrats take the House and the Senate, uh we don't believe that very much would change.
Uh first of all, Trump holds the veto until the end of his term uh and a narrow Senate, which is uh what I believe is projected to happen, a narrow Democratic Senate.
uh it still needs Republican votes to move uh stricter legislation uh forward, but it's true that the thing that both parties agree on is making uh large electricity users pay for their own uh grit costs.
Um and Trump supports that as well.
Um so what is most likely to happen is that um the the the developers may have to pay upfront um or or po post more uh collateral and that can delay some projects but it doesn't prohibit development.
And so the permitting reforms could actually speed up uh the infrastructure that the the new demand needs. Makes >> sense. >> Yeah.
One thing that I'm struck by listening to all of this is that at every level, like federal, state, local, it does seem like there's lots of politicians being pragmatic and thinking these issues through on their merit rather than having this like party line they have to stick to, even if it doesn't make sense in their specific scenario for their constituents, which is encouraging.
like this is an important topic and I think it's actually quite nice to see that not everybody has, you know, one line they need to stick to and they're going to actually think these things through.
I don't know what you guys you guys agree on that or >> Yeah, I think uh politicians are listening to their constituents.
Uh we're also doing some work, it's still ongoing on better understanding this anti-data center backlash that is really a 2026 phenomenon.
Um so stay tuned for that.
Yeah, on the last podcast bring this topic up every time like people have a more favorable rating like a significantly more favorable rating for AI than they do data centers >> and they really like to log onto social media and post online to all their friends to see on the internet about how much they don't like data centers.
Yeah, there's definitely a lot of fear-mongering online and some yeah, some social media posts that have gone viral um that are like clickbait uh and that have been widely reshared.
So, I think data centers uh are slowly realizing that they really need to have a better PR strategy. >> Yeah, makes sense.
Wayne, how do how do you think data centers can improve their PR strategy? What do you think?
I think, you know, Amazon and Google, you know, is a good start that they're ending the NDAs, right?
I mean, that gives the perception that there's like something secret going on or that politicians are in in the pockets of these companies, you know, because of it. Um, yeah, I don't know.
I think that uh yeah, I'm pure is a pretty powerful thing.
Uh, but if you can show that uh it benefits the community, right?
community, right? There's like definitely all these examples of data center coming in and like adding like public utilities or adding like a fire station you know that wasn't there before or you know playgrounds and
things like I mean I think that there's like there's there's a lot of like economically underdeveloped you know towns especially in like West Texas that I think the by by bringing in data centers it'll you know it could definitely have a material impact on the economy. I think that that story needs
I think that that story needs to be told more.
Uh and another thing is like with water and the environment too, right?
There's just so much misinformation about um water and electricity.
A lot of these hyperscalers, you know, they're like the largest buyers of renewable energy, right?
Or they, you know, or they, you know, put out more energy or they try to put out ex, you know, as much energy as they, you know, can, you know, versus what they take in.
And so it's like net zero.
And I think that a lot of people don't realize that.
And I think some of the uncertainty surrounding AI also feeds in to the the general uh opposition to data centers.
Um it was one of the representatives that I interviewed actually was saying, you know, people don't know what's going to happen to their jobs.
Uh they don't know uh what kind of future they're leaving to their kids.
And so having a data center being built in their backyard um just doesn't make sense to them.
And she did say, which I found funny, you know, like if data center developers were hanging up Christmas lights, then we wouldn't be opposed to them.
[gasps] >> Interesting PR strategy. Yeah.
I uh one thing you guys didn't bring up is jobs.
I think um like it's fascinating.
I I went to visit a data center.
I won't say where it was or who it was visiting, but I got to talk to a lot of people working in construction because it was under construction at that time.
And um you know, it's it's significantly biased because it's all the people that chose to work there.
But uh they were all very much in favor of this project and talking about how important it's been to them and their families and how they know people who are driving for, you know, as far as like an hour and a half, two hours away every day just for this job and it's high paying, it's good for the community, things like that.
When you hear Jeremy talk about the percentage of money that's spent on the GPUs and how expensive the building is and stuff, maybe it's not the absolute best like jobs program, you know, 50 billion for a few thousand jobs is probably like a bad trade, but there is some stuff for the local community when you think about all that investment that comes in and people having their jobs where that is a that is a good thing.
Um, and then the meta story about uh the teachers getting a yearly bonus, you know, based on the uh taxes that they were paying in that uh site in Louisiana.
I think that's that's one that they show off quite a bit, but it's a pretty good one. Um, quick take.
What do you think about the financial incentives?
Like literally just paying people more money, giving jobs, local taxes.
Can data centers, you know, builders, construction, can they just like pay more money for this problem to go away with sentiment towards their sites?
>> I don't think paying I think I don't think paying people like $10,000 each will get them to will get them to go away, right?
I don't think that's like an effective >> strategy or or Yeah. Yeah.
At least that's what the people we talked to on the ground say, right?
It's going to take more than just paying them off.
You know, some people don't want to be paid off. Yeah.
Another thing is a representative in or somebody running for uh the board of supervisors in in Iowa which um is crucial for approving certain projects in unincorporated um counties in Iowa where um data centers are being lowered because of cheap land and power.
He was saying that um the uh a lot of the jobs that are coming in to build these data centers aren't local.
You know, they're being like, you know, they're brought in from other states or even, you know, from other countries.
So, um, so it's not really benefiting the local community's job market.
>> Yeah, they're specialists.
I mean, maybe the view there is training where I think a lot of people still feel like this is a fad that's going to go away.
They're going to build some data centers and then a few years from now they're going to tear them all down.
We're going to forget about that AI thing as opposed to being this like inevitable change where there's just going to be more and more of this over time.
Um Maya, what's your take on like direct payments or I I think I wasn't necessarily saying we should go out and pay everybody as like a policy proposal, but the tax incentives going away thing seems like the most obvious next step where there's so much demand for data centers, the supply demand balance has changed and the local governments or the states don't need to provide tax incentives to people to get them to build there.
And so that's probably going to go away quickly.
And that just means more money for local community.
Yeah, I think it should just be a more comprehensive process that involves more transparency, uh, no more NDAs, educating the the community, explaining, uh, also that new data centers don't consume as much water, uh, are not as environmentally uh, aggressive.
Um, and also contributing to the local community, I think, can help, not in the way of like bribing and giving each person $10,000, but perhaps uh building a school, uh, building roads.
I think this this is something that has been appreciated in the cases that we've seen where it's been done. >> Cool. Awesome. Okay.
What have uh what have we missed going through here?
What are you guys watching today as the election plays out?
>> I guess Texas and Georgia for me. >> Yeah, same. Same.
Texas is the biggest one and Georgia is the one where it's really a toss up.
So, it could go either way. >> Awesome.
Thanks for the rundown, guys. Appreciate it.
Good job with the article and yeah, talk to you again soon.
>> Thanks so much, Jordan. >> Thanks, Jordan.