0:00
all right everybody Welcome to episode 149 of the Allin podcast with me again David saaks and chamat poopa David freeberg couldn't make it this week we're going to carry on without him and it's a difficult week so just a quick
Search this video
0:15
opening statement from me about this episode like all of you we're devastated by the terrorist attacks that occurred in Israel on Saturday and I just want to start the discussion here with two important housekeeping notes first uh this is obviously a very Dynamic
0:28
situation and we're dealing with the fog of War quite literally so we're going to do our best to make sense of what's happening but things will change between when we tape this episode on Thursday and you choose to listen to it in all
0:41
likelihood at some point over the weekend and second there are going to be some folks out there who claim quite correctly that we are not the experts on this topic and thus we shouldn't chime in with our opinions on the other side the all-in community has told me
0:55
explicitly they want to hear us discuss uh what happened and they want a sense of normaly as one loyal listener explained to me last night at a dinner the fact that the four of you can debate hard topics listen to each other and in
1:07
the end have a deeper understanding of the world gives me hope every week that's why I listen so uh we'll do what we do here every week we'll have the hard discussion we'll listen to each other deeply hopefully and we'll try to understand the world and each other just
1:19
a little bit more and that's worth it at least to me and apparently many of you so with those two quick disclaimers gentlemen anything you want to say up front before I recap where we are 5 days into this senseless brutality I think
1:34
that was a pretty good intro Jason I mean you're right we're taping on Thursday late morning Pacific Time by the time this drops it'll be Friday and so a lot could have happened also it's true that the Middle East in general and this topic in particular is hugely
1:50
complicated we will be accused of not being experts but at the same time the audience seems to appreciate our opinions as consumers of information who are trying to make sense to the world yeah so that's all we can really do
2:04
right and conversations I think are how we make progress any any thoughts before we get started here and I'll recap what's occurred toat any any um opening thoughts before we get into the details here on behalf of somebody who worked in Israel have a lot of
2:22
friends there spent a lot of time there it's really just a terrible devastating situation I've really tried to stay off of social media just because it's allowed me to kind of think a little bit more logically it's fast and furious right now I think on
2:43
X and it's just a lot of people trying to make sure that their version of the truth is Amplified over every other version of the truth which I think is like a is a point in the cycle where you you just have to almost unplug from The Matrix a little bit and
3:00
find a few places that seem to be just telling things in an even-handed way which I also find on X and then just kind of reconstruct what happened why it happened what do we do from here I don't know I don't I I have a lot of thoughts
3:15
on a lot of the peripheral issues but the core issue is just I'm just stunned that this happened I don't I don't even know how this is possible that this happen like jamath I'm not trying to get too weighed in too deeply into the tweet but I did notice you by the way have
3:32
stopped tweeting you've done a couple of retweets but youve paused this week a lot of your tweeting yeah I mean I think that important time to listen and learn and process what's going on right this is not a great time to be having hot takes
3:48
I have posted a few things first of all Jason you've made the analogy to to 911 being in in New York right now I think that that is the comparison that's been made is that this is Israel's 911 yeah I think that's a justifiable comp comparison in in two
4:01
respects one is this was a terrorist attack it was an atrocity this was a a massacre of of civilians even if you're somebody who believes in the Palestinian cause you should be able to recognize that these were war crimes yeah the videos are coming out the stories are
4:17
coming out in particular the rounding up and Slaughter of 260 attendees at a music festival was really Beyond The Pale they're clearing some of these uh farming villages and so forth and finding the bodies you know families basically killed anyway we
4:36
don't need to repeat all all the details here but um but this was I think an attack on civilians that is reminiscent of of 911 and and um has affected the Israeli people in a similar way I think the other analogy to 911 that's worth discussing is the reaction
4:55
to this or what what Israel's going to do and what the reaction is by us political figures you heard people like Nikki Haley basically saying to to nah who finished them it wasn't exactly clear whether she was just talking about
5:11
Hamas or the whole Gaza Strip or maybe Iran and then if there was any ambiguity about that you just had Lindsey Graham come out and say level the place meaning referring to all of Gaza yeah it's crazy I'm very concerned that one of the
5:26
purposes here of of the terrorists was provoke an overreaction like the US uh engaged in after 911 remember we were viciously attacked we were wounded we then lashed out and plunged into two decades of wars in the Middle East what was the result of that we lost thousands
5:45
of lives of our own soldiers we spent trillions of our treasure millions of people on the other side died yeah and we at the end of the day we only changed the geopolitical map of the Middle East in ways that were ultimately unfavorable for us
6:00
Iran became a more powerful country the region became destabilized and we squandered uh the sympathy that the United States had and its moral position that we had after 911 in the eyes of much of the world so the US I think fell for the Trap that I
6:17
think Bin Laden laid which was to provoke us into an overreaction I think that is one of the goals of terrorists is to create such an outrage such a provocation that they will bait the other side into an overreaction I'm quite concerned that could happen here I
6:31
think that our us leaders should be as friends of Israel should be counseling a cool-headed response I think braying for war with Iran or suggesting that the entire Gaza Strip should be level would be doing exactly the wrong thing it would ignite
6:49
the Arab Street the Middle East perhaps that was the goal here and we're trying to figure out what is the goal of this attack that was planned for years and perhaps that was the goal is to try to take all the hard for it peace and progress that has
7:04
been made in that uh process over the over the last couple years Abraham Accords and and you know stability and then just you know really create a fullscale escalation I think that's right I mean look I think Israel is within its rights to dismantle and
7:20
Destroy Hamas Hamas is an organization that in its Charter has said they're committed to the destruction of Israel they've now committed this atrocity again it was if they had just limited their attack on uniformed Israeli officers and Military I think that would
7:37
be one thing but they went much further than that the vast majority of the casualties here are civilians who were murdered in atrocious ways so I think they're a terrorist organization and Israel is well within its rights to
7:49
destroy them however the question is how you do that yeah like a lot of terrorist organizations Hamas can kind of Melt Away into the population of Gaza they've apparently have these elaborate tunnel networks they've got bunkers so it's not
8:03
clear that you can destroy them from the sky through uh bombing those kinds of bombs would lead to a lot of Civilian casualties which will inflame the situation and turn a world opinion against Israel at the same time if they go in with ground forces that seems like
8:22
a really tough situation as well because Hamas is waiting for them and they they will have to fight a Guerilla war in a very tight packed dense urban area where Hamas likely has anti-tank weapons weapons that we've seen that have been so
8:36
effective against armored vehicles in Ukraine again if the uh fighting gets too hot they can disappear into these tunnel networks there's going to be IEDs everywhere it's going to be a very very tough fight for the Israelis so I think they're in an incredibly tough spot I'm
8:53
not quite sure what the right reaction is for them but I do think that if the reaction is this uh let's call it the Lindsey Graham level the place reaction I think that could set off a much wider Regional war or even a World War and that is not something that's
9:12
ultimately going to help Israel and I hope that our leaders are wise enough to be counseling against that I get the sense that they're not going to uh go that hard and if you look at the American response to 911 you know going
9:24
into Afghanistan and dismantling al- Qaeda a noble Mission and we didn't have any terrorist attacks on America or very we thred most terrorist attacks there were attempts actually and our intelligence was very strong over the last couple of decades and we haven't
9:38
had another one of those but you're right going into Iraq and then you know what what was the last decade about being in Afghanistan we went into Iraq we went into Syria we went into Libya we stayed in Afghanistan for 20 years it
9:50
should have been a quick surgical strike to take out al- Qaeda and their Taliban hosts and then we should have gotten out and even that is incredibly difficult as a as you're pointing out here you know Hamas can just fade away into the Gaza
10:03
Strip and into into Palestine and you know who knows um shamat I guess where we're at right now is trying to make sense of why this happened and what the next couple of weeks might look like right and so your thoughts I think Israel has every right
10:20
to defend itself and they should eradicate Hamas this is not like we woke up and found out that they were a terrorist organization yesterday or on Sunday we've known this for years they've been labeled as such people have been monitoring their money flows for
10:36
years we know where they were funded but the thing to keep in mind is that those 30,000 Hamas terrorists have also been keeping 2.2 Palestinians hostage for the last 20 years and of the 2.2 million Palestinians in Gaza half are kids and so David's right the thing
10:59
thing to keep in mind is as barbaric as what happened to the Israelis were Israel in its actions could cause tremendous civilian casualties which will just further inflame the ability to find a long-term peace in the Middle East that's really
11:19
tragic and that's probably part of hamas's kind of sadistic calculus which is they they probably expected this kind of a reaction and they probably don't Care at the end of the day so it's important to separate Palestinians from Hamas but I understand
11:37
and I know where Israel is coming from because we fa the same reaction after 911 the question that I have is Israel is the most sophisticated military and intelligence organization in the world and the reason is because when everybody talks about
11:57
priorities Israel only really has one priority which is to safeguard the Israeli people yeah survive and they've been essentially in a conflict Zone with this Sword of Damocles since the founding of Israel so there are three organizations
12:18
that really have to figure out what happened here right there's mad which is the foreign intelligence service of Israel there shinb which is the domestic security apparatus and then there's Aman which is the military intelligence group
12:33
and it's like how did this happen because this should have been priority 1 two three and four right and it has always been for them other countries the safeguarding of their people is not necessarily always number one right and then things happen and then you rep
12:48
prioritize in many ways that's what happened in 911 I guess at some level in America I mean we had all the signal before that and when we did the 911 Commission and we found out they were going to flight school here you know and and it was pretty
13:02
clear that it was an intelligence failure for America yeah those are the two big thoughts that I have which is there's just going to be so many civilian casualties what will that do to actually I think that that has a huge negative impact on the long-term chances
13:17
of Peace because then radicals will use that information to further or to attempt to radicalize the next generation of Palestinians or other Arabs or whatever and so I worry that the progress that was made in the Abraham Accords all the [Music]
13:33
normalization goes off the rails and that's tragic because most of these people the overwhelming majority of all people everywhere they just want peace they just want to live a decent life take care of their family raise their kids so that's really tragic but then
13:49
the other the other part of my mind is like how could this have fallen through the cracks and and why were the most sophisticated int Ence organizations caught flat footed here yeah there's going to be a a lot of uh information
14:05
that will come out over time and lessons and by the way the reason why that second piece is important is not to point the finger at anybody but it's to deescalate because of what sack said earlier which is that when people who can articulately gird for war are given
14:20
the bully pulpit and you see American politicians now braying and ging for War I don't think they fully recognize the consequences of that they're not doing a full accounting of what America has lived through in the last quarter century and now to induce other
14:38
countries to try to do the same I think is so dangerous and so yeah if we can understand where these cracks are at least we can deescalate those specific individuals attempts to escalate and if we don't do that we're going to find ourselves in a
14:55
really complicated war and I don't think anybody wants that nobody wins nobody wins yeah I mean at at this point really the returning of the hostages seems to be the most important you know high order mission that has to occur after that clearly
15:14
dismantling Hamas and this Terra apparatus but you know having started to spend some time you know in the region and talking to people over there and again I'm no expert but I have been talking to people who've been working on this you know got people who've been
15:28
working on trying to create peace in the region for their entire lives and this is definitely a setback but I'm an optimist and I actually think that in some ways this is going to create a climate where people are going to really fight to try to uh resolve this
15:44
situation or at least contain the situation two- State solusion the Abraham Accords I think they're this is going to renew people's commitment to peace in the region and I I know many many of the countries over there are really a Gass
15:59
at what happened and they've been working really hard to try to normalize relations there and create peace and prosperity and commerce and you know uh between uh the different countries in the region so this is just heartbreaking
16:12
uh for the loss of human life and how that occurred and then it's also heartbreaking for the peace process and all this progress that's been made recently and so I think it's you know the there's no Silver Lining here but I I do think this will uh maybe the good
16:29
people of the world will recommit to trying to resolve this issue and create peace in the region that's my hope I know it's simplistic and uh again no expert but that's my hope and I've been spending time over there and learning a lot more
16:43
about the region these These are multigenerational issues that are going to take generations to figure out um and it's it's two steps forward one step back obviously uh but man for the politicians and the the people negotiating this piece and they work re
16:58
tiously on this for their whole lives you know keep at it I mean that's all we can do right I mean Jason I think disrupting the process that was happening towards normalization of relations between Israel and Arab states specifically the gulf monarchies I think
17:15
was one of the objectives here yeah so I mean Israel's contention for a long time is they want to negotiate peace they they want to negotiate but they don't have a partner to negotiate with whether you believe that or not that was that
17:27
was their position and with the Abraham Accords we saw that they started to be able to negotiate again normalization with three Gulf Arab states without involving the Palestinians and it looked like that issue was being put to one side and that they were kind of going
17:48
around it and the idea being look if if you won't negotiate with us then we'll figure out a way to move forward without you the big news that you know been going on in the last few months is that supposedly Israel and Saudi Arabia were close
18:02
to working out some sort of normalization and I think that process has been put on hold until I think this has been dealt with and so I think one of the takeaways here is the idea that you're going to be able to get to Middle
18:15
East peace without resolving this Palestinian question I think this is basically a a return to to the reality that that issue is simply going to have to be dealt with I don't think we're going to get to a larger deal in the Middle East we're not going toble to
18:31
resolve all these problems until this long festering problem of of the treatment of the Palestinians is is dealt with I think you're right that the two-state solution is the only possible solution that makes sense I mean what's the alternative a one-state
18:50
solution means that either it's run by the Israelis but presiding over hostile Palestinian minority that may eventually one day be the majority and you're forced into some sort of aparti State or the Palestinians are running that one party State and it means that
19:10
the Jews have been pushed into the sea so neither one of those Solutions looks very good so that leaves you with a two-state solution however hard however impossible it seems to negotiate that it's the only option yeah it's the only option and it's a real opportunity I
19:27
think the my hope is that instead of pushing Saudi away this actually pulls Saudi closer and says okay this is a chance to really normalize the global perception of the Middle East because if there can be a way for Israel and Saudi to build a
19:44
bridge here I have a lot of hope that there can be a lot of stability and a lot of the good work I mean again like man as a Democrat who has been left homeless who is now now definitely in the center but probably leaning increasingly right
20:03
I left yet again with an appreciation despite the messenger of the message of the Trump administration because what those guys did was pretty incredible in hindsight these Abraham Accords the Accords with Israel and the GCC the almost Accord
20:20
between Israel and Saudi to really be able to like find a longlasting peace is just a real example for the world and those guys did a lot of really good work and it's it's a miracle actually when you when you look at it what they did
20:38
you know despite the fact listen I'm no fan of trump and I am too homeless this is where party but if you want to objectively look at what they did it was good work it was great you have to and in fact this is a moment where you have to start to rewrite like is your not you
20:56
Jason but I'm just saying collectively is one Trump derangement syndrome causing more damage than anything that Trump could have actually done and I think the answer is yes because like it's now causing us to not see that good work and then Embrace and
21:12
extended so much of the work that happened in that Administration turns out to have been right and that's what's so frustrating for me the work on the border wall we didn't like the messenger so we killed the message turned out it was right
21:28
issuing long-term debt to refinance when rates were at zero we didn't like the messenger so we killed the message a structural piece in the Middle East we didn't like the messenger so we killed the message when are we going to stop shooting ourselves in the foot and
21:44
when are we going to actually see and take the time to look past who is saying things and actually listen to them word for word I'll give you an example I started to tweet Three Links a day over the past 3 days and the only reason I
22:00
did that was I thought things were so hyper contentious and Hyper partisan that I just wanted to show a few sides right and one day I found a couple links two of which one was from Jonathan greenblat of the ADL who I thought had a very powerful message and one was from
22:18
Mike Flynn and his message was also actually pretty powerful if you just read it and if you took the names off all the content was so valuable both points of view but the minute it goes into the world people immediately judge and they
22:33
kill the message because of the messenger and this is exactly a moment where you have an opportunity to just stop doing that because the stakes are so high it's infuriating actually quite honestly it's infuriating to see it we had this last week on the show when we
22:47
were talking about reducing spending the Matt Gates is not the perfect messenger but his message was the message we've been talking about which is hey we have to control spending so you I can understand people not liking Mett Gates
22:59
there's a lot of things to not like about I I understand people not liking Trump and get over it well and then you know it's it's bizarre that his son-in-law went to do all this work but yet he did it and it had success that's another example it's weird your
23:15
son-in-law to do it but I listen to the podcast you know what it's not weird because at the end if you listen to this podcast the most important thing that is resoundingly obvious about Jared Kushner is that he is incredibly thoughtful and
23:30
Incredibly competent and right why did we have to spend years being fed all of these stupid lies because one can judge for oneself but Jared Kushner is thoughtful he's smart and I thought to myself I was fed all these lies for years about how
23:50
this guy was like moping around in the shadows and this and that and was all not true well no when I say it's it's non-traditional if you sent you know any presidents son-in-law daughter-in-law whatever child to go to the Middle East
24:07
on its surface this seems insane but in fact he they did good work and so it's not traditional it's not what you would expect he's thoughtful and competent that's what I thought after I that's what I got out of it as well is that he's thoughtful and competent yeah yeah
24:22
he brought some fresh ideas just so the audience is clear what we're talking about is he just did an interview with Lex Freedman and the first hour was on what's happening with Israel and Hamas must must watch I think I thought it was
24:33
excellent too excellent excellent it was excellent he did just in terms of having fresh eyes he did things like focus groups he's like what does what does the Arab Street think about various topics and he actually did focus groups in
24:46
various countries to find out so I mean I think kusher made a number of really interesting points showing how difficult it's going to be to get to a two-state solution But first you have to set up what does the the Palestinian side say and what they say is look Gaza is
25:00
effectively an open air prison you've got over two million people packed into this very tight area there's something like 50% unemployment it's impoverished the conditions are deplorable and they don't have their own State they don't
25:13
have rights and it's been like this for a long time so that's sort of the the basic Pro Palestinian argument kushner's response to that was well yeah but you know Israel left in 2006 it left Hamas in control gave them the keys effect ly the reason why there's such high
25:30
unemployment is because Hamas is corrupt and doesn't enforce property rights and they scare away all the investment nobody wants to invest there yeah and Israel did give work permits so people could leave Gaza to go to work and look what happened I mean when they try to
25:45
open up the walls you have a massacre so these are the points that he made look I think both sides of this have legitimate arguments and points to make I think that the conditions of the Palestinians in Gaza is deplorable and you have to
26:01
feel for the civilians who live there of course but then you know the the Israelis have a right to live without fear the fear that their security is in Jeopardy and that this territory can be the launching pad for terrorist attacks
26:15
on their soil yeah so it's going to be an extremely difficult thing I think to to reconcile this but you know K Kushner made a couple other interesting points he said listen the Gaza part of this is not that hard because the boundaries the ter
26:28
lines are not in dispute there's no religious areas that are in dispute for example you don't have the status of the Temple Mount or you know East Jerusalem and there's an economic plan to revitalize Gaza Strip so you really just
26:40
need a negotiating partner for the Israelis to to figure that out and of course now the problem is who do you negotiate with I mean hamus is is a terrorist organization that is dedicated to the destruction of Israel so it's really a tragic situation you you look
26:57
at at it and you're like this should be easy to work out but it's not it's a relatively small area it's a relatively small number of people it's it's it's two million people we we should be able to figure out the rest of the Free World how to at least have a path towards this
27:12
and the first step is getting rid of Hamas right like there's no choice but they have to go Jason I mean look if if there was a if there was a button that Israel could push to eliminate every member of Hamas yeah sure they'd be within the rights to
27:27
to push that the problem is that Hamas is now deeply yeah embedded in a civilian population over over two million that's densely packed how do you root them out it's going to take decades it's going to take decades and they're basically
27:43
supported by that population as far as we can tell yeah and you know again if you if you take measures that are perceived as too drastic by the rest of the world then you will inflame the opinion of other countries you'll turn it against Israel so again it's a really tough
28:01
situation but I think that the US should not only affirm its support for Israel it should only denounce the atrocity that happened on 107 but I think it needs to reiterate the Biden Administration does its support for a
28:15
two-state solution I think that the US has to be on record that what's in everybody's long-term interest including Israel is ultimately a two-state solution and the Palestinians are eventually going to have to have their own State there's simply no way around
28:29
that right yeah and the the Free World I think is in the process of getting engaged in making this happen because it's in everybody's interest this can't keep going on um and so hopefully this again I don't want to say Silver Lining
28:45
but I I hope that this the good that comes out of this is that the world focuses on resolving this conflict or were you surprised at all Jason by the amount of people that seem to be almost justifying that was shocking to me I mean I I the the fact that people could
29:02
make any kind of equivalence between terrorist activity and the the level of brutality I I can't even describe it because it'll trigger my PTSD which I I had after 911 and it's still affects me I'm sitting here not far from ground zero and you know for people
29:20
you know educated people on College's campuses or just otherwise to blame the Israelis for the murder of children for people being and then justifying rape and torture kidnapping I mean there is no justification and there is no equivalency there's no equivalency here
29:40
and and this is one of the big problems and you know these Dopey kids on Harvard's campus or whatever they have never experienced evil suffering we can we literally just dismiss these idiots because these are kids who have never fa
29:57
I don't think you can I think one of the things that was shocking to me was the level of basically either subtle or latent anti-Semitism unconscious yeah subtle whatever that it unlocked and I was also shocked it just Sak has used this word before but it's true but
30:17
our leading educational institutions have really become woke madrasas they are inculcating kids with just some virent poison I think the reaction is always to go after to support the underdog I think in this group of people that that is a that is an idiotic
30:34
simplification that the smartest schools in the world educating the smartest kids in the world should be capable that's how they think though it can't be that not my feeling on I think that there's it's half anti-Semitism and it's half they just think who's the
30:48
underdog I'm taking that side yeah I think it's that simple is in the woke mindset yeah well look I think it was disgusting and disturb iring to see these organizations and these Elite institutions being unable to denounce hamas's terrorist attack and the
31:06
atrocity that took place or turning out in the streets to celebrate what happened and we saw a lot of that too look even if you support the Palestinian cause even if you believe that they've been mistreated even if you think that
31:20
their land has been occupi they deserve their own State even if you believe that war against the state of Israel is Justified on that basis these were still war crimes these were Beyond The Pale of War again Hamas did not just attack some
31:39
military installations on the border and kill soldiers or capture Soldiers the vast majority of the people who were killed were civilians and there was no conceivable military purpose in for example paragliding into a music festival a festival for Peace by the way
31:56
and then rounding and slaughtering the concert goers there was no conceivable military justification for going into these kotzas or farming communities you know families it's deranged it's deranged it's deranged so it's deranged it's
32:11
terrorism and the fact that they can't frame it as terrorism is insane but think about what happened okay I just want to frame the order of events okay 107 happens and I think within 36 hours or less let's take Harvard as an example okay the the P of the W
32:28
madrasas they had all these student organizations immediately come out trying to justify this thing without any information right because in the first 36 hours obviously not nearly as much information was available as to exactly what happened than it's been available
32:43
now as an example I should read the statement just so people have Clarity here joint joint statement by Harvard Palestine Palestine solidarity groups on the situation in Palestine we the undersigned student organizations hold Israeli the Israeli
32:59
regime entirely responsible for all unfolding violence today's events did not occur in a vacuum for the last two decades millions of Palestinians in Gaza have been forced to live in an open air prison Israeli officials promised to quote open the gates of hell and the
33:14
massacres in Gaza have already commenced Palestine Palestinians in Gaza have no shelters or for refuge and nowhere to escape in the coming days palestin Palestinians will be forced to Bear the full brunt of Israel's violence this is
33:28
derang sociopathic my point is you talk you have like 15 or 20 of these student organizations of all ilks okay so it's not just Pro Palestinian groups it was like the Harvard siks Association okay like siks in South Asia are the most
33:43
peaceloving people in the world they're not pro-war of any kind whatsoever or Pro terrorism so all these people write this thing which blames Israel okay then the school is totally silent the school doesn't say anything they neither they
33:59
neither completely disavow that statement nor do they come out with a more reasonable statement all these ex faculty and ex individuals Larry Summers sort of leading say this is outrageous have an opinion they come out with
34:14
something that's milk toast in middle of the road then they get sadly rejected by everybody yet again then the administration comes out and gives a cleaned upb version that tries to allay everybody's anger CU that the first statement I think basically essentially
34:27
pissed off everybody on both sides then a bunch of alums who've already graduated or who've given money say these student organizations are outrageous we will not hire anybody who's part of this because their views are so immoral that we would never
34:45
want these people part of our organization and so here it isman just so we people have this bill Amman said I have been asked by a number of CEOs if Harvard would release a list of the members of each of the Harvard organizations that have issued the
34:58
letter assigning Soul responsibly for hamas's heinous acts to Israel so as to ensure that none of us inadvertently hire any of their members in other words you must own your words which is an important lesson for so then what happens is individual students actually
35:15
have to come out who are part of these associations that were signatories to the first release had to disavow the statement and said actually I'm just an Indian student at Harvard Law School there's Nick maybe you can find this
35:28
tweet of this like Indian woman from Colorado of Indian Heritage and she's like you just get Auto recruited into these organizations when you join Harvard so I'm like well wait a minute this is a place that's supposed to be for like
35:42
modern Free Speech Progressive thinking and instead what happens is based on your skin color you get autod drafted into some Association then you autosign any press release written by some person that you don't even see or approve what is going on at these places and these
35:57
are the places that parents and kids are tripping over themselves trying to get into kids will kill themselves if they don't get into and these are the worst institutions in America because back to Jason what we talked about earlier which
36:10
is we need people who can think from first principles those kids are not it and those institutions are not making them and so if we want to have a point in time where when things like this happen we can really figure out what happened in the past that was right and
36:24
what can we do in the future it's not this and it's not this kind of thinking and if you're going to a school Harvard Cornell upen Stanford that are spitting out these kids I think it's a real shame your spot on I mean how Sachs could there any be
36:42
any question about the difference between military terrorists you know with machine guns gunning down people dancing peacefully at a music festival at Sunrise and then make some equivalency there it and you cannot actually ascertain for yourself that is a
37:02
terrorist act if you can't from very basically opening your eyes and seeing what occurred and you know thank God in some ways for for X not being censored because you can actually see these things and I know it's very difficult for people to watch I don't have any
37:16
judgment on people who don't want to watch it but I think when the world sees these videos and you going to write this letter you should very quickly be able to discern milit AR terrorist fighters from hippie kids dancing at a music festival it's it's
37:35
plain as day there's there's nothing there's nothing to confuse you here this is the most easy test you you have to be brainwashed to see something other than that these schools are woke madrassas yeah so a couple of points on that so if
37:49
you look at their statement I think it's it's uh appropriate and fine to express concern about the people the civilians living in Gaza and what the Israeli response might entail I think it is fine and and good to do that both for humanitarian reasons
38:07
and for self-interested reasons if you're a supporter of Israel because this could all spiral out of control however these people completely lit their credibility on fire from the first paragraph by saying that Israel was entirely responsible for what happened
38:23
and not having one word of condemnation for the atrocities that had just been committed they cannot even see the war crimes that have occurred yeah they don't even mention Hamas they don't even mention the actual people that perpetrated the crime right
38:39
so the question is why you know what is it about their idiology that blinds them to this atrocious Massacre and and I think it is this I do think it has to do with this this woke mindset the the woke ideology is a form of cultural Marxism
38:56
in which which people are divided up into oppressor and oppressed groups so in Marx's original teaching you had the proletarian and the bisi basically the oppress and the oppressor this kind of went through this cultural identity filter with woke where
39:13
again people are divided up into identity groups and so you've got men versus women white versus black and brown you've got straight versus gay and so on down the line and the the idea is that there's a power structure and if you are
39:29
in one of these groups and you are by definition oppressed and if you are in one of the uh oppressor groups then by definition you are guilty in a collective way you you're suffering from by default the people who are oppressed are the Righteous ones yeah right but I
39:47
think that what you see is that when you divide up the world this way first of all is this not a very accurate way of looking at the world I mean there are lots of minority groups in the United States that have done great so for
39:59
example there's a book written recently about asian-americans in the United States called the inconvenient minority why is it inconvenient because asian-americans have done spectacularly well they get into Elite colleges and institutions at higher rates than than
40:15
whites do which is why they're the primary group that's discriminated against by affirmative action before it was overturned by the Supreme Court but the reason why the author called them the inconvenient minority is because the
40:26
their success in America refutes a lot of this sort of simplistic woke delineation between if you're a minority group you're oppressed and if you're you know in this white group you're the oppressor I think Jews have fallen into a similar type of categorization which
40:43
is they're An Inconvenient minority they've been historically very successful in America despite their being existence of of anti-Semitism and I think that the woke ideology has reacted to this by saying no you know Jews are not really an ethnic group
40:59
they're just whites and so that's been the response right is well let's just put them in the oppressor group so we don't need to explain away their success one of the problems with that is that you have to ignore the existence of anti-Semitism and so they do they just
41:13
pretend like it doesn't exist so here you have a situation where all of these things are in play they've already predefined the Palestinians as being an oppressed people and and look and I think in many ways they are but they are not incorrect yeah not incorrect but
41:28
they've defined it in in racial terms really right right and they've defined the Israelis and and Jews really more generally as being part of an impressor group and so everything fits into that larger narrative and so when members of
41:43
one of these woke oppressed groups commits an injustice they just can't see it I mean their version of social justice is always defined in terms of collective guilt and if you're a member of an oppressed Group by definition you're not capable of committing an
41:58
injustice because you don't have the power do you guys think that bill Amman was out of line by saying I don't want to hire kids from these organizations and these schools because it's just like these kids and these schools will bring
42:13
basically I think what he's implicitly saying is distraction and it will lower the probability that I achieve my corporate goals so these are not good workers based on your comment about thinking from first principles and and
42:26
you know being able to assess the situation I think that's probably what happens at a hedge fund you have to place bets and you have to be able to think from first principles and be intellectually rigorous this is the most intellectually lazy approach I'm just
42:39
going to sign a piece of paper without even thinking so no I don't think it's out of line I think it's an important lesson for people this is not freedom of speech this is owning your words you must own your words in position and it's
42:50
important that young people learn this now you have to own your words whether it's on social media or signing some stupid petition that you didn't read and and there's a lot of backtracking going on right now by the way I can't believe that if I got into Harvard I would get
43:03
autod drafted into the brown men's association just because of the color of my skin I've ever heard fat GRE group I mean let's point out the double standard here that these Elite Harvard students want to be exempt from their their words
43:18
their statements they don't want to be canceled for that however you know that when some haa schmuck basically posts some tweet or posted a tweet 10 years ago that gets resurfaced they're the first ones clamoring for their cancellation right yeah they would like
43:35
for their firing they would like amnesty for their idiotic opinions yeah well it's good good for the goose here is good for the gander if they're they're going to create a cancel culture where people get cancelled for their decade old tweets and so forth then they should
43:49
be prepared to live by that standard now look personally I would have some degree of forgiveness for a college student being part of an organization that puts out a statement they're claiming they didn't know okay but then why didn't you
44:02
resign look I don't think there's a good excuse for this other than youthful stupidity so I would I wouldn't cancel them forever but look I do think that it's fine for inappropriate for someone like Bill and say I don't want to hire you people yeah and I would just be
44:16
careful for you to add the word youthful because I think it's just get out of jail free card it's definitely stupidity the question is is the cake baked and if the cake is baked then there's a big argument to never hiring these people I
44:29
mean look your frontal loes are still developing until you're 25 years old so I I would give college kids a bit of a pass if they do stupid stuff you're there to learn you're there to make mistakes no that's not what I'm saying
44:40
this is a huge mistake you're saying the bakes fully baked you mean like their their opinions and who they are are I'm saying is you learn a lot from actions drink too much Don't drink don't exercise enough you get a little sluggish maybe a little overweight I get
44:52
all of that I'm not convinced that when you have this fundamentally specific way of thinking that you can unwind that so easily Jason so I'm not convinced yeah okay sure that this mind virus gets fixed because you all of a sudden need a job I actually
45:11
think like maybe it's the struggle of realizing that there are deep consequences to this vein of thinking that this oppressed versus oppressor or the other way that it was framed in our group chat is that wokeism and the
45:23
embracement of socialism is basically running away from Excellence it's this idea that everybody has to be the same what communism says we all are the same nobody is special we're all going to work together do the same things we're
45:37
all going to dress in the same ways it's the collective we there aren't going to be exceptional outliers but the problem is that's not how the world works and so the other part of why these woke madrasas are so terrible is that it teaches I think to work away from
45:54
excellence and instead of striving for excellence to strive to be part of a collective and I think that that is fundamentally corrosive to America it's corrosive to what God is here it's corrosive to all the great countries in the world and so then again it's like why
46:08
would you hire kids who fundamentally don't want to be excellent who are afraid that if they were excellent they would be guilty of something that's ultimately the question why why would any of these kids go to such an elag school to basically
46:23
be taught that it's wrong to excel all right well let say I think perhaps a good set and then as a result not think for yourself and then as a result sign something like this which is just stupid we'll continue to discuss this topic I
46:37
guess in the weeks ahead again hopefully this conversation was productive for the community the all-in community I understand that you know people might have very strong feelings about you know us discussing it but we're here to discuss difficult topics
46:53
there's one other aspect to this I think we should talk about which is the the United States's larger geopolitical situation right now I mean things seem very tenuous I did an event with um Paul Merl lucky actually friend of the of the
47:06
Pod friend of the Pod tell them I said my invite got lost yeah we we actually had a nice uh debate SL discussion on on Ukraine but the thing that I think we agree with is that the US better bring more Innovation at the milit military industrial complex and and figure out
47:25
like procurement because our whole Cost Plus system right now is so broken there's an article recently in the New York Times where it said that the cost to the United States of producing an artillery shell is $6,000 for Russia it's
47:37
$600 so in other words it costs the US 10 times what it cost Russia to produce an artillery shell even though Russia is considered to be this super corrupt kleptocracy where everyone steals everything and yet our procurement system is 10 times more than their we
47:53
don't have competition and all the politician are captured correct we have this Cost Plus accounting system where every year the price good opportunity to explain that yeah so in every other part of technology price goes down over time
48:07
right you can produce more of something for Less we've seen this with Tesla we've seen it with PCS we've seen it with television sets whatever it is the price goes down over time servers yeah or if the price goes up it's because you've developed some fundamentally new
48:23
capability some new version you know the powerful chips more storage exactly faster speed but you know we're still making the same artillery shells the same Stinger missiles the same javelins and so forth I don't think the capabilities have changed that much but
48:38
the price goes up every year because it's Cost Plus and so explain Cost Plus people might be hearing that for the first time well you know most companies sell something and then they have a profit margin but right the way that
48:49
government procurement works is the profit margin is controlled they're only allowed to Market up a certain certain amount above their cost but the thing that's happened in the defense industry is there's been huge consolidation over the past couple of decades where now
49:02
you've got a handful a defense companies and it's an oligopoly and many of these key armaments are single source so there's only one producer and they just keep raising the price every year now one of the kind of crazy things about this is
49:18
and Palmer made this point is it's not like anyone's getting rich because of cost plus it's not like the money is basically making these companies there's no incentive to lower the price if you lower the price and you're at 10% and
49:32
you got your $6,000 down to 4,000 10% of 4,000 is a lot less than 10% of 6,000 what's happening is not incentive Google like margins what's happening is that these companies keep building their bureaucracies bigger and bigger so they hire lots of Staff they make a lot of
49:48
campaign contributions they fund think tanks and so their cost structure just keeps getting more and more bloated right their incen to do that the more they charge the more they make right now why am I bringing this up well we're in
50:00
a situation now where Israel might be on the precipice of well they've declared war against Gaza and this thing could spiral out of control and become a regional War they may be asking for weapons yeah they may be asking for weapons we've already donated some
50:15
however earlier this year we used to have an ammunition stockpile in Israel the United States did it it belonged to us but it was there potentially in case of problem in the region and that artillery stockpile was basically taken and given to Ukraine and remember we ran
50:34
out of the key type of ammunition in the Ukraine war which is 155 millimeter artillery shells that's why we gave them cluster bombs so the US is already dangerously low on ammunition and that's before we get potentially another war or
50:53
another front in this larger another country's War to be clear we're not at War but we've been asked to donate weapons to Ukraine and we've been asked to donate I think Israel have asked for weapons I don't know if they formally asked but uh we are obviously
51:09
going to think there's a uh Bill making its way through right now that's going to give some Aid to military assistance to Israel by the way we have Israel also a builder of of weapons too I mean their their drone technology is incredibly refined and they sell weapons
51:25
to Russia and yeah Israel is nowhere near the Ukraine situation Ukraine is 100% dependent on the United States for its military and for its economy Israel has a vibrant military and economy without the United States but the United
51:40
States does make long-term security guarantees to Israel not to fight its Wars there's no neutral defense treaty however we do agree to provide them with weapons in the event of a war so we do have obligations like long-standing obligations to them this is an ally
51:57
we've had for 75 years however our stockpiles are dangerously depleted now because of the Ukraine war and on top of that our procurement system is hopelessly broken so in a world of rising multipolarity where there are other great Powers now in the system
52:16
where there are going to be more and more Global threats I don't think we have a a chance of maintaining our Global position and supporting our allies unless we fix this I mean making artillery shells at 10 times more than
52:29
what it cost Russia that's ridiculous in Silicon Valley we have now the funding of military startups and there's a whole new class of warfare SuperSonics drones qu is the only Advantage we have it's the only Advantage we right I mean this
52:44
is one of the great things I mean I understand Palmer is not a huge fan of mine but I'm a huge fan of the work he's doing and other entrepreneurs are doing to make new weapons to keep us competitive because you can be sure China's making them and so I think it's
52:58
absolutely fantastic I thought it was always very weird that Google speaking of work madrasas like Google was Google employees were refusing to provide services like even basic Cloud hosting services to the military that that to to to benefit from
53:15
democracy and Living in America while then not supporting the military just seemed like the ultimate luxury belief to use um Rob's term from the PA in s your thoughts what does it take guys to for this fever to break for for all of these people to realize that that
53:35
level of corruption is not sustainable that the these ways of thinking are not sustainable that it's not a path to peace and prosperity that we actually want excellence in society we want people to be outliers we want the whole of humanity to move forward and that's
53:50
not going to happen when we move necessarily as one blob but a few people need to sort of clear the brush and lead the way and the rest of us will come in and fill it in behind them I think V is the manifestation of it I'll be totally
54:02
honest like I think the reason he is going up in the poles and the reason people are drawn to him is because he's smart and he's exceptional and he represents one of the great things about America is that there's people who want to win and
54:16
they're smart and Excellence he represents Excellence right he represents Excell I I think that's why people are drawn to him and I think people are tired of complex they're tired of corruption they're tired of geriatric you know 80-year-old
54:30
politicians we need young successful people to take leadership position and by the way I I really agree with what you're saying I think that there's like Excellence can show itself in different forms I think why Obama was so profound
54:42
and Joe Rogan said this was he was such a Statesman he was the best of us but he demonstrated excellence in being composed and measured and thoughtful and strategic he was just so excellent um Clinton as well Clinton as well Clinton was incredibly steeped in policy he was
55:04
excellent he was intellectually a massive outlier Obama is an intellectual outlier vivec is an intellectual outlier let's get these people to change and run our system of government please I think we're soaking in it yeah we need smarter more capable
55:22
people I mean you look at Biden when he gave that speech uh in support of Israel I mean a lot of the words were right but he was like slurring his way through it it certainly did not inspire me confidence it was it was his best speech and it was
55:34
concerning the fact that he's clearly incognitive decline you can see it in his ability to orate and you know it was his best speech and it was also troubling for me as somebody who voted for him to watch him slur his words or just not it was clear he wasn't all
55:49
there and you're like gez what are we showing to the world if this is the guy who's running the country and if we reelect him now we're saying hey we we want to have an 84 yearold running the country who's not all there and is in
55:59
cognitive CL let the guy retire let let him spend time with his grandkids I think it's more people who are willing to vote for not for what they want but to prevent something else and I think that that's of course that's what's so tragic
56:12
about how we're thinking as a country right now yeah and just just to dish it out equally I mean I saw Trump give a a recent speech where look he's nowhere near the cognitive decline of Biden I think he's still Compass men but he's not as sharp as he used to be
56:27
either I mean listen I think America's basic situation and this has really been reaffirmed over the past week is that we're no longer in unipolarity anymore we're no longer the sole superpower yeah not for some time China is now a
56:40
superpower they're probably the lowcost manufacturer of the world so when we talk about being able to make things like armaments and artillery shells and weapons they have the ability to outproduce us that is very scary there are other great powers in the system now
56:53
Russia has proven over for the last 5 months through his victory in this counter offensive that it is a power to be reckoned with we cannot disregard their concerns anymore and not only does America need I think topf flight leaders
57:07
like intellectually who are at the top of their game but we also need new thinking we need to be able to sidestep challenges and conflicts as opposed to walking into every single trap the way that lindsy Graham wants us to again I'll go back on the Ukraine
57:22
war I think it's really clear that we could have avoided that war if we had taken NATO expansion off the table it and whether you believe that or not it was criminal not to try if it was a five% chance it was worth trying so I you and now look at our situation we're
57:37
already Meed in the Ukraine proxy war now Israel's on the brink we need smarter people and smarter thinking in Washington we are no longer the only superpower we're going to have a really tough time in a multi-polar world if we do not look for ways to
57:52
deescalate conflict when we can or putting aside conflict why are we not building deep ties with as many countries as possible deep cultural ties deep economic ties deep diplomatic ties every time we are in dialogue with a country and we're building a
58:10
relationship with that country that means free people of the world are winning you know and every time we isolate a country that does not go well for us sanctioning half the world that's another big part of this problem yeah and so you know it's the normalization
58:24
of relationships and the deepening of relationships that is the high order bit and you need somebody in office who can do that and you know if you look at how the you know the Hawks in the GOP or the Hawks in the Democratic party think they
58:38
think that we have to be at war with everybody they think we have to isolate everybody you know the fact that Trump went and that famous moment where he walked over the in the DMZ in North Korea and was talking to Kim Jong Un that moment you see on
58:53
Kim jong-un's face we we can put it in here he is so happy to be recognized now listen I understand suffering he has a shocked look on his face like I can't believe this is happening right the same way he did when Dennis Rodman came over
59:05
no it's like it's like a fan meeting Taylor Swift if you look at those videos and you compare it to this it's the same well and and culture is our export and I know this sounds you're talking about Jason is soft simplistic it can't all be it can't all
59:17
be hard power because other countries have it too now so we have to work on our soft power but you're not going to enhance American soft power with all this belligerent rhetoric really this omnidirectional belligerence that's coming out of Washington and this is why
59:31
I think the smart thing for blinkin to do or the Biden Administration is yes you reaffirm that you stand with Israel in the face of this unspeakable atrocity at the same time and you don't have to do this right now because it is a little
59:45
bit tough to do it right now but hostages you have to re reaffirm your support for the two-state solution that I think the United States has always supported and by the way I think I think Tony's done a really good job but again at the end of the day Tony works for
59:59
President Biden and it's like Biden hasn't been nearly as definitive as he could have been and Tony's had to clean it up so one example of this is like in the Wall Street Journal they immediately on Sunday that went to blaming Iran
1:00:14
right and then both the Israeli military intelligence and American intelligence they had to do an entire press circuit to try to disarm this in a way that was not seen in a long time and you have to ask yourself why why is that even happening
1:00:29
and it's like well whatever special interests wanted to get that on the front page of the Wall Street Journal was able to do it but it has dangerous implications and then what you need is a really strong leader that can step up and say this is false this is not
1:00:42
happening this is what we need you needed an Obama in that situation and I think that this is Clinton yeah or Clinton Reagan and and I think that this is an opportunity for us to ask ourselves okay who is the most dynamic excellent
1:00:59
candidate that can give us this and be open-minded and not make this line about Republican versus Democrat right now because the world is getting super complicated we need someone hyper hyper excellent and intellectually competent well I will say this for for
1:01:17
Trump is that um he's the only president in recent memory who didn't give us any new Wars best quality yeah I think he has despite despite all of his issues I think he has a unique ability to project strength to the American public while
1:01:33
not being one of these super Hawks he's actually I'd say relatively dovish well he he actually walked through his secret plan he's he said I can't remember where this clip but he said whenever he met with these folks he basically left a 10% chance that he would nuke
1:01:47
them that's what he said and it turned out that that 10% was just enough where the where everybody everybody to stay in line it was just see I see I I think the US already has enough deterrence I think we've maxed out on deterrence I think
1:02:01
the thing that was smart about Trump was that he was willing to do business yes he was willing to negotiate and he didn't feel the need to make these moral condemnations all the time he was willing to meet with Kim jongo and he was willing to meet with Putin and and
1:02:18
Sean ping and he avoided uh criticizing them personally he didn't call them dictators he talked about how smart they are yeah it's the art of the deal right I mean at the end of the day he's looking to do business and we need a
1:02:31
little bit more of that and I think this is why jerck kusher was successful is he went in there with the mindset of a businessman yeah how do we find something that's beneficial to both sides totally right I think that when Trump was elected I was told that it was
1:02:44
the end of the world and that's what I thought and I'd already underwritten him as an F okay and then four years into the presidency he was probably like a C in my mind and then as I get a little bit of distance away I realized no hold
1:03:00
on a second this guy was like a BB Plus like he was pretty good and unfortunately the few things that if he if he could have just pushed through would have really saved America the biggest one being these hundred-year bonds it it would have kept America from
1:03:17
getting to the precipice of fiscal ruin and we'd be in a highly different situation and I'm not sure we could have ever given him credit for it but the further and further I get away from him and the less emotional I am he did a
1:03:29
pretty good job he was a pretty good president don't forget that he tried to overturn the election and steal the election I voted for Hillary Clinton I voted for Joe Biden but this is the honest assessment the guy did for the things that he was supposed to do a good
1:03:42
job and for where every other president found a way to frankly make our situation a little bit worse specifically around Wars he did not do that and that is a huge accomplishment that I think needs to be acknowledged and he would have ripped up the
1:03:57
Constitution and taken the presidency and stolen it so just give that in mind as well L we get him that that's why he's not that's why he's not an a he's a b B+ okay Jason you have to admit if it weren't for the Black Swan of Co he
1:04:13
would have been reelected in a Landslide Landslide it's quite possible he would have been reelected yeah I mean I and also yeah by the way I mean at this rate the way things are going in this country right now both economically and internationally he's going to Wal the
1:04:28
white house he's going to spend all of his time in the next year in in the cour houses battling all these lawsuits the law fair against him he's not going to be able to campaign and it won't even matter because people are going to be so
1:04:40
done with this and nobody wants him as president again so I think that's nobody wants that everybody wants new choices all right everybody if you do not want to hear us talk about complex issues in the world you can unsubscribe from the Pod we're going to be here every week
1:04:54
having hard discussions listening to each other and learning together uh you don't have to agree with any one of us uh but we are um we're happy to have the difficult conversations and learn every week here and your our thoughts and prayers
1:05:12
go out to the families and the friends of those impacted by this heinous terrorist attack and I I don't know if anybody has any other closing remarks here but obviously we're heartbroken and we we hope that peace prevails and that the
1:05:28
hostages are released as quickly as possible well said all right everybody this is episode 149 of the all-in podcast uh next week we'll we'll talk about all the different topics but for this week we're going to let it sit where it is right now see you next time bye-bye